[00:07] Speaker 1: Good afternoon, everyone. This meeting will come to order. Welcome to the November 16th, 2026 regular meeting of the Land Use and Transportation Committee of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors. I am Supervisor Miriam Melgar, chair of this committee, joined by Vice Chair Supervisor Cheyenne Chen and Supervisor Matt Dorsey. The committee clerk today is John Carroll, and I would also like to thank Eugene Libadia at SF Gov TV for staffing us during this meeting. Mr. Clerk, do you have any announcements? Yes, thank you, Madam Chair. [00:38] Speaker 2: Please ensure that you've silenced your cell phones and other electronic devices you've brought with you into the chamber today. If you have any documents to be included as part of any of today's files, you can submit those documents directly to me. Public comment will be taken on each item on today's agenda. When your item of interest comes up and public comment is called, please line up to speak along your right-hand side of this room. Alternatively, you may submit public comment in writing in either of the following ways. [01:00] Speaker 1: First, you may email your comment to me at johncarroll@sfgov.org, or you may send your written comments via U.S. [01:09] Speaker 2: Postal Service to our office in City Hall. The address is 1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place, Room 244, San Francisco, California 94102. If you submit public— if you submit public comment in writing, I will forward your comments to the members of this committee, and I'll also include your comments as part of the official file on which you are commenting. [01:27] Speaker 1: Items acted upon today are expected to appear on the Board of Supervisors agenda of December 1st, 2026, unless otherwise stated. [01:35] Speaker 2: Thank you. [01:38] Speaker 1: Mr. Clerk, please, uh, call item number 1. [01:40] Speaker 2: Agenda item number 1 is an ordinance amending the Administrative Code to clarify requirements and raise the threshold for evicting residential tenants due to nuisances, prohibit eviction due to property damage when landlords have allowed tenants to pay for the damage, extend the statute of limitations period for wrongful eviction claims to 3 years with limited exceptions and deleting certain obsolete provisions. [02:00] Speaker 1: Thank you so much, Mr. Clerk. Uh, colleagues, I believe, uh, the legislation before us today will make a substantial difference in the number of evictions we are seeing in the city. Uh, we have seen an increase, uh, in, uh, eviction filings due to nuisance, uh, a steep one at that. And I am proud to have worked on this legislation with both the Anti-Displacement Coalition and the Apartment Owners Association. Eviction notices for nuisance are the fastest-growing category of at-fault notices according to the Rent Board. We have heard that our city's Right to Counsel program is nearing a breaking point due to the volume of work that eviction defense attorneys are responding to. In one year's time, there has been a 41% increase in nuisance petitions. I don't believe that tenants across the city are 41% more annoying now. I think that there's something going on with the market. So we have heard of a building in Chinatown where 6 different households received nuisance notices by the same landlord who had recently acquired the building, which points to an alternative reason for the increase. In these nuisance petitions. We must ensure that there is fairness in eviction so that tenants are not defending themselves against unsubstantiated rumors or minor claims, while also ensuring the rights of landlords to remove truly problematic tenants and to do our responsibility as a city to support folks who need help. I will offer some amendments to address the concerns from the Apartment Owners Association when there is a problematic behavior that affects neighboring buildings as well. But before that, let's take public comment, please, Mr. Clerk. I don't see anyone on the roster. Oh, okay, Supervisor Chen. [04:04] Speaker 3: Thank you. [04:08] Speaker 1: Thank you, Supervisor Melgar. Chair Melgar, this is really a very important legislation. We know that the rate of eviction based on alleged Tenant nuisance has been surging across San Francisco. Too often, these cases are alleged nuisance are pretexted to evict longstanding vulnerable tenants who benefit from rent control. The tenants who are most vulnerable to this trend are those who have lived in their units for a long time, particularly seniors and low- and middle-income working families. Under this legislation, landlords can continue to evict tenants who are causing genuine nuisances. What this legislation does is clarify that, tighten the standard for nuisance evictions so that landlords may not evict over issues that are insubstantial. I believe this will prevent landlords from misusing this eviction pathway and help to preserve communities and stabilize vulnerable population with established roots in San Francisco. Thank you again, Chair Melga. Thank you, Supervisor. With that, Mr. Clerk, let's go to public comment on this item, please. [05:19] Speaker 2: Thank you, Madam Chair. Land Use and Transportation will now hear public comment related to agenda item number 1. Members of the public who wish to speak on this item should line up to speak along that right-hand side of this room along the curtains. Each speaker will have 2 minutes. [05:32] Speaker 1: There will be a soft chime when you hear— sorry, there will be soft chime when you have 30 seconds remaining, and then there will be a louder chime when your time has expired and we need to move on to the next speaker. [05:40] Speaker 2: The board currently has a rule that addresses disorderly public comment and prohibits speakers from addressing an individual member of the committee, regardless of whether they are providing comments that are in support of or detracting from matter, which also includes thanking a supervisor directly. Please do not say thank you to any supervisor or address them directly. [05:59] Speaker 1: Let's get the first speaker coming forward to the lectern, and I'll start your time when you begin. [06:02] Speaker 2: Good afternoon, members of the committee. My name is Justin Goodman, and I am here today to speak on behalf of the Coalition for Better Housing. CBH believes that the current language in the rent ordinance protecting both landlords and tenants from nuisance behavior is critical to maintaining the safety of the building and the community. San Francisco has a proud tradition of strong tenant protections. Some tenants, however, engage in nuisance behavior which endangers other occupants landlords, vendors, service providers, and the community at large. Even when the victims of this bad behavior include other occupants in the building, tenants are often fearful of retaliation and are therefore reluctant to participate in the litigation required to solve the problem. CBH believes it is critical to retain the current language providing standing to landlords to prosecute nuisance behavior. And as a separate matter, CBH believes that the statute of limitations on wrongful endeavors should not be extended. The appropriate lawsuit for wrongful endeavors to recover possession seeks vindication for egregious behavior. The violations are obvious and the lawsuits are swift. This extension is not necessary to achieve the purpose of this ordinance. These lawsuits necessarily cannot be based on nuisance evictions themselves. The majority of these claims are sundry add-ons to personal injury lawsuits which needlessly stress the marketplace for essential insurance policies that allow housing providers to enter this tightly regulated industry. CBH asks that this provision just be removed. Thank you very much. Thank you for your comments. Let's have the next speaker, please. [07:39] Speaker 1: Good afternoon. Shelby Nacino, managing attorney for the Housing Rights Program at Asian Law Caucus, or ALC. ALC has long-standingly provided direct legal services in San Francisco. We counsel and represent over 200 tenants per year on a wide range of issues, Ranging from habitability to rent increases, landlord harassment, and evictions. We're here today to speak in support of the ordinance clarifying and tightening the definition of nuisance. The AI boom has increased rents throughout the city, resulting in increasing incidents of tenants experiencing pressure, whether it be through eviction notices, rent increases, or bald-faced harassment. Today's ordinance will help to protect tenants from one of the pressures that long-term tenants are facing: flimsy allegations aimed at long-term tenants. Innocuous day-to-day conduct. In ALC's work serving tenants, we have seen numerous instances of tenants receiving hasty or exaggerated notices through a variety of tactics. Seniors with long-term rent control tenancies are particularly at risk. In one case, a senior who had lived in his home for over 20 years received a notice asserting that he was creating a nuisance. Roughly a dozen of his neighbors also received similar notices. In another case, an 88-year-old senior received an eviction notice threatening her North Beach home of several decades based on allegations that she had flooded her unit. When our office visited the unit, we found a beautiful apartment maintained in excellent condition. Situations like these should not involve an eviction notice in the first place. With the clarifications provided by today's ordinance, it is our hope that San Francisco's property owners and managers will better understand the level of severity necessary to support eviction. We urge them to compassionately work with residents and reserve nuisance evictions only for instances of real serious harm. Thank you. [09:24] Speaker 3: Thank you. [09:24] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. To the next speaker, please. [09:26] Speaker 1: Good afternoon. My name is Haley Meyerhoff. I'm with the Housing Rights Committee, and I'm here today in support of Supervisor Melgar's legislation. I specifically work with tenants in buildings owned by large corporate landlords, so I see up close the ways that these corporations are using your constituents' housing to enrich their companies at tenants' expense. Many corporate landlords maximize their profits by intentionally displacing the tenants that keep this city running in order to rent out units at current market rate. One of the ways they can do this is with nuisance evictions. [10:01] Speaker 2: With nuisance eviction as it stands, a landlord can get around just cause protections with a vague or manufactured complaint. A tenant our organization worked with received a 3-day notice for nuisance in 2025 on a claim that they were being loud late into the evening. [10:15] Speaker 1: It came as a surprise to the tenant who had been abiding by quiet hours stipulated in the lease. Our office supported the tenant to write a letter to the landlord asking for more explanation, and they received no response until a year later when the landlord issued yet another 3-day notice for nuisance on the same claim, which we then had to help them fight off again. In this case, the vague nuisance definitions led this landlord to use 3-day notices without explanation to harass this tenant. [10:40] Speaker 2: and to cost the city resources to avoid a bogus eviction. [10:44] Speaker 1: Long-term rent-controlled tenants have long been most vulnerable to this kind of nuisance allegation because corporations stand to make the most profit from kicking them out of renting their unit at market rate. However, with monthly rents up more than $1,000 in the last year, there is a target on the back of any tenant who has been in their unit for more than a couple of years. The rent is skyrocketing, and this is just the beginning. [11:06] Speaker 4: Thank you. [11:06] Speaker 1: If you don't close this loophole now, we will see many more examples like the seniors at 1120 Jackson Street, and we will see our city drained of the people who make San Francisco the diverse city we love. I urge the board, please close the nuisance loophole to protect all San Francisco tenants. Thank you. [11:22] Speaker 2: Thank you for comments. Next speaker, please. [11:30] Speaker 1: Good afternoon, supervisors. My name is Zachary Frial, D5 resident with SOMCAN. [11:34] Speaker 2: SOMCAN supports the legislation before you today in the midst of our current rent emergency, we believe it is imperative for the city to close loopholes with existing eviction protections. Several of our clients have received nuisance-related eviction notices for trivial matters like leaving shoes outside their unit or hanging clothes outside to dry. Tenants should not be punished for cultural norms or simply existing within their units. And even if these charges get dismissed, the eviction notice and process can be highly disruptive and distressful for tenants. We appreciate the supervisors for proposing this legislation today and for sponsoring it. Please continue to work with tenant rights advocates to strengthen existing eviction protections and to keep our community members housed. Thank you so much. Thank you for your comments. Next speaker, please. [12:19] Speaker 1: Good afternoon, supervisors. [12:25] Speaker 2: My name is Hannah Berkheimer, and I'm with the Housing Rights Committee. I'm here today in support of Supervisor Melgar's legislation. We know that rent in San Francisco is skyrocketing. [12:33] Speaker 1: Landlords who rent— [12:34] Speaker 2: who own rent-controlled apartments are looking to capitalize on these new housing prices by finding any excuse to evict tenants to be able to raise the price of rent. People and families who have lived and worked in San Francisco for decades are facing eviction when they shouldn't be. This legislation would be used to protect these families, allowing them to keep their homes in the city they have made their homes. Thank you, Supervisor Melgar, for bringing forward this legislation, and to Supervisors Soder, Fielder, and Chen for their co-sponsorship. Thank you for comments. [13:03] Speaker 1: Next speaker, please. [13:03] Speaker 2: Good afternoon, supervisors. My name is Peter Stevens with the San Francisco Tenants Union. We are here in support of Supervisor Melgar's legislation. Rents are up. Landlords are looking to cash in at the expense of tenants. Please support this legislation and keep our tenants housed, healthy, and living dignified lives. Thank you very much. Thank you for comments. Next speaker, please. [13:28] Speaker 5: Good afternoon. [13:28] Speaker 3: My name is Ken Wong. I am a resident at 1120 Jackson Street. [13:33] Speaker 2: I am here to speak in support of Supervisor Melgar's proposed ordinance. 1120 Jackson Street was sold in July 2025, and shortly after that, 6 seniors in our 16-unit building received eviction notices accusing them of having too many things in their apartments. [13:54] Speaker 3: Including my mother-in-law, Sue Yen, who is 92 years old and have lived at 1120 Jackson Street since 1982. [14:04] Speaker 2: The notice said that she had committed or caused a nuisance. We were all shocked. My mother-in-law lived peacefully at the unit for many years. [14:16] Speaker 3: No one ever complained about her. [14:18] Speaker 4: Thank you. [14:20] Speaker 2: After we retired from a decade-long job at Self-Help for the Elderly, she was enjoying her golden years in her apartment surrounded by family and our neighbors. So the notice made her very anxious. She was very scared and could barely eat and could not sleep at night. [14:42] Speaker 3: She would open her apartment door often to see if any more notices have been posted on her door. [14:49] Speaker 2: She was depressed and afraid that she could become homeless. My family and I feel that Sue Yen got an eviction notice because the new land— the new owner rather rent the unit to someone who could pay more. We urge the Board of Supervisors to protect seniors and long-term tenants like Sue Yen by clarifying the Definition of nuisance. [15:15] Speaker 3: Unreasonable nuisance accusations could not be hastily used against long-term tenants. [15:23] Speaker 2: This type of careless eviction notices really hurt our seniors. [15:27] Speaker 6: Thank you. [15:28] Speaker 1: Thank you for your comments. [15:29] Speaker 2: To the next speaker, please. Hi, supervisors. My name is Enrique with the Housing Rights Committee. I'm also here in support of Melgar's legislation. Yeah, I just want to say we know how the corporate landlords are talking about tenants in these buildings. That basically they can make— if someone buys it, they can make a tidy profit, 225% increase in whatever, as long as they're able to get the tenants out, right? It's very dehumanizing. It's very— yeah, just really, really horrible language. And one of the ways that they were able to get folks out is because of how loose the language is in this— in the current legislation. So I really encourage you all to support this change. We need more protections for tenants in the city, not less. [16:10] Speaker 1: Thank you. [16:12] Speaker 2: I encourage you all to use whatever power you have, all the power you have, to make sure that seniors, families, children are not on the street like they already are. Okay, thank you. Thank you for your comments. Next speaker, please. [16:23] Speaker 1: Good afternoon, honourable members. [16:30] Speaker 3: My name is Yvonne Lee. [16:32] Speaker 1: I've lived in a rent-controlled apartment building for over 38 years. I'm here to urge you to pass this ordinance because renters like me need tighter protection against unjust evictions. [16:47] Speaker 2: About a year and a half ago, investment groups— an investment group bought my apartment building, and shortly after that, I received a rent increase notice for a 30% rent increase. At the time, I was not able to fight it. [17:06] Speaker 3: So I paid the rent increase. [17:09] Speaker 1: About a month after that, I received a— I saw a notice, eviction notice, posted outside my door. At that time, I didn't think much of it because the stated reason for the eviction was nuisance. And because of my traveling schedule, I was hardly home even to be a nuisance to myself. But during the— afterwards, I went to the rent board site to really review what nuisance really meant. And that brought— [17:49] Speaker 7: I got really scared. [17:51] Speaker 1: During my almost 4 decades living in the apartment building, I have not received one not one complaint inquiry from the— from my neighbors and management company. But when I reviewed the Rent Board's definition of what a nuisance eviction was, it brought me a lot of concern because under the current law, the way it was written, I could be evicted because there was no clear, objective, measurable guidelines to define what qualified as a nuisance and therefore a justified eviction. [18:32] Speaker 8: I was fortunate— [18:32] Speaker 1: Speaker's time has concluded. [18:33] Speaker 2: Thank you for sharing your comments with the committee. Okay, thank you. Let's have the next speaker, please. Good afternoon, Supervisors. Joseph Smook with People Power Media, a member organization of the San Francisco Anti-Displacement Coalition and a District 1 resident. I hope that this committee sends Supervisor Melgar's legislation to the full board with a unanimously positive recommendation. I've been tracking for-sale listings of multi-unit properties, and as the market has been heating up, it's alarming how many are advertised that the property will be, quote, delivered vacant, or describing the property as having immediate upside potential. Realtors use language like frictionless to describe how easy it will be to get existing tenants out. This legislation is important because it creates a clearer definition of nuisance and also clarifies the threshold for what can be Resulting in an eviction. Clarity benefits both tenants and landlords. Under the current definition, landlords are able to threaten vulnerable tenants, especially seniors, immigrants, households with low incomes whose rents might be well below current market rents, and tenants feel they don't have any tools to defend themselves. I used to work as an organizer and tenant coordinator with Housing Rights Committee. This legislation will provide tenant counselors with important clarity in the definition. of what constitutes a nuisance and what the consequences are based on severity. Please support Chair Melgar's important legislation to make sure our most vulnerable tenants are not needlessly evicted from their homes and displaced from our communities. [20:02] Speaker 8: Thank you. [20:02] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. Next speaker, please. [20:04] Speaker 1: Good afternoon, supervisors. My name is Meg Heisler. I am here on behalf of the San Francisco Anti-Displacement Coalition. I'm not allowed to say names anymore. To the supervisors for supporting this legislation, working very hard on it with us. We all know, as has been described by past speakers, that there's an immense amount of pressure bearing down on rent-controlled tenants right now, whether because their landlords want to increase the value of the building by selling it empty, reset the rent to market rate, or merge units to create bigger apartments. [20:43] Speaker 4: Thank you. [20:44] Speaker 1: to sell. As was the case 10 to 15 years ago during the last tech boom, landlords will get very creative in how they do this. So when it comes to nuisance evictions, as was mentioned, it's clear something's up. The, the Rent Board registered a 41% increase in nuisance evictions between fiscal year '24-'25 and fiscal year '25-'26. So it's our role as tenant advocates to track trends and threats. And the board's responsibility as policymakers to be responsive to the conditions as they're playing out on the ground, and that is what we're doing here. So thank you again to all the co-sponsors of this legislation for taking the issue seriously and removing the ambiguity in the law that has led to enough abuse as is. Thank you. [21:30] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. The next speaker, please. [21:34] Speaker 1: Hello, I support this legislation and any legislation that prevents. evictions, hence preventing homelessness. UCSF released this in 2022: Older homeless people are at great risk of dying. Research describes a health shock from losing housing later in life. A quarter of the participants in a long-term study of older people experiencing homelessness in Oakland died within a few years of being enrolled, UC San Francisco researchers found. The study, funded by the National Institute on Aging, recruited people who were 50 and older and homeless. and followed them for a median of 4.5 years. By interviewing people every 6 months about their health and housing status, researchers were able to examine how things like regaining housing, using drugs, and having various chronic conditions such as diabetes affect their risk of dying. They found that people who first became homeless at age 50 or later were about 60% more likely to die than those who had become homeless earlier in life. But homelessness was a risk for everyone, and those who remained homeless were about 80% more likely to die than those who were able to return to housing. And so I just want to remind y'all that legislation like this is literally life and death legislation. And I have been in a lot of meetings where anti-homeless people legislation has gone through, unfortunately. And there has been this one elder woman named Melody who showed up to so many meetings to advocate for herself because she was disabled and homeless as well. And I remember her in this chamber last year screaming that the mayor has money for my coffin. She just wanted money for her coffin at that point. So hopefully, I don't know if you know where Melody is, but we really need to not let that happen anymore. [23:14] Speaker 2: Thank you for comments. Next speaker, please. Good afternoon, supervisors. I'm Mitch Lomerberg with the Affordable Housing Alliance and the San Francisco Anti-Displacement Coalition. Well, we're all pretty aware of the fact that under our ordinance, if the land— if the landlord can get the unit to be vacant, then they can raise the rent as much as they want. [23:36] Speaker 3: There's no limit on that. [23:37] Speaker 2: And, you know, that's just a big temptation for some landlords. And nuisance is one of the ways that we've seen increasingly used to evict people for pretty trivial reasons. So this legislation tries to be a little more precise there, raise the bar a little bit. and protect tenants where it's not really a problem. So thank you, Supervisor Melgar, and the co-sponsors of this legislation. Please don't thank an individual member of the committee. Let's have the next speaker, please. [24:08] Speaker 3: Good afternoon, supervisors. [24:12] Speaker 2: I am typically here to ask you to approve a new building or to pass legislation that would streamline the production of more housing. But while we wait for all those things to come into effect to address the housing shortage, which is driving our affordability crisis, I think it's equally important that the city continue to protect the residents and tenants who are at the mercy of moneyed interests who can take advantage of laws to evict them from their homes. So thank you for this legislation, and I look forward to seeing its passage. Thank you for your comments. [24:47] Speaker 1: Next speaker, please. Hello, my name is Ronnie Diamant Wilson. And I'm just, I'm actually not here to speak on this legislation, but I decided to anyway. I'm a landlord, and I've been a landlord since 1999, and I decided to become a landlord. It's a 3-unit building in order to provide low-income housing, and I'm really sorry that it has gotten worse in the 30 years that I've been here. So thank you very much for this legislation. [25:20] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. Next speaker, please. [25:23] Speaker 1: Hello. Ann Kolochitis, Gray Panthers of San Francisco. We support this change in the language. [25:36] Speaker 2: It's so— [25:36] Speaker 1: nuisance is used as such a frivolous accusation for tenants, and so anything that we can do to make eviction more difficult is— and especially like the person before talked about older adults. It seems like wave after wave after wave of older adults as we reach a certain age, we've been in our places for a while, and we're much more vulnerable to the market. Thank you. [26:04] Speaker 2: Thank you for comments. The next speaker, please. Hi, I'm Honest Charlie Bodkin. I'm the co-founder of San Franciscans for Social Housing. I'm here to support this legislation. Nuisance evictions have increased 41% in the past year, and I share Supervisor Melgar's belief that it's hard to believe that San Franciscan tenants become 41% more annoying. We've heard about seniors who have lived in their homes for decades now who are facing eviction over allegedly having too many belongings. And at a time when the count of homeless children in this city is up 20% 7%, and at a time when rents are through the roof, so much so that people are losing their roofs at record rates, we cannot ignore the financial incentive that landlords have that may lead them to push longtime tenants out. We talk a lot about addressing homelessness, about the billions of dollars we ought to be spending on affordable housing. But the easiest person to house is somebody who is already housed. We cannot hope to solve homelessness if we allow people to lose their homes faster than we build new ones. Please support this legislation. [27:24] Speaker 5: Thank you. [27:25] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. Next speaker, please. [27:32] Speaker 1: Good afternoon, supervisors. My name is Janan New with the San Francisco Apartment Association. I'd first like to thank Chair Melgar for working with our office on trying to achieve— [27:43] Speaker 2: Please don't think I'm reaching over the board. [27:44] Speaker 1: The goals of protecting tenants in place while also trying to crack down on the truly bad actors that are causing problems for other tenants in the building, life safety threats to other tenants in the building. Actually, the nuisance eviction filings are 0.14% of the percentage compared to the rental housing units in San Francisco. That's a very small percentage of filings, and not all of those result in an eviction. And as much as we were referring to 1120 Jackson in these hearings, all of those tenants are in place. There were no evictions in that building. Everybody's still in occupancy. The one thing we want to make sure of is we have a board member, Oz Erickson, that was just in our office talking about his building down the street here. He had a problem tenant that would strip naked every night and run through the hallways banging on people's doors. One night he got the hose, the fire hose, And let it go in the building, causing $14 million worth of damage, displacing 3 floors of tenants. We want to prevent that from happening so those other tenants aren't displaced. Thank you so much for listening. [29:11] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. So the next speaker, please. Good afternoon, supervisors. Gen Fujioka from Chinatown Community Development Center. We very much appreciate Supervisor Melgar's office's work on this legislation. It is indeed very needed, and as well as the co-sponsors. I just wanted to respond to what Janet Nguyen just spoke of with respect to the Jackson Street case, and I'm familiar with that case, worked with the Asian Law Caucus in defending the tenants. It was only because of concerted action in the community, in the media, and for— that prevented those tenants from being evicted, that kind of harassment, which went on for weeks, months, in fact, Repeated notices was imposed extraordinary stress on those tenants. Some of the tenants continue to face challenges at the building, and so it really is an is in a crack statement. I just want to respond that that that it required the tremendous amount of public. engagement, involvement from the supervisor's office, and the threat of this legislation for the landlord to back off. And that's not the kind of action that should be necessary in order to protect vulnerable tenants in this city. [30:54] Speaker 5: Thank you. [30:54] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. Do we have anyone else who has public comment for agenda item number 1? Madam Chair? [31:00] Speaker 1: Okay, public comment on this item is now closed. Supervisor Dorsey. [31:05] Speaker 2: Thank you, Chair Melgar. I share the concerns motivating this proposed ordinance, and I am grateful to Chair Melgar for her leadership in bringing it forward. I have seen plenty of booms and busts during my time in city government, including portions of it when I worked in the City Attorney's Office that actually pursued litigation against predatory landlords who sought to exploit the demand shocks that sometimes happen to our supply-constrained residential rental market. We saw that in the City Apartments case years ago. We saw it in the Anakiagi case more recently. We've seen these fears are not hypothetical. So we have to be vigilant against predatory market actors. Given that we're seeing an uptick in nuisance evictions and that some of those are in bad faith, to push out long-term tenants, it makes sense to tighten the rules. I also understand and appreciate counterarguments that if there's legitimate nuisances in buildings, whether it's violence or fire hazards, conditions that endanger somebody's health or safety, or really anything that denies residents the quiet enjoyment of their home, the tenants deserve to be protected from that too. In fact, we heard about the 3 floors of tenants at 100 Van Ness Avenue, those were my constituents who were displaced because of malicious conduct by a fellow tenant. But I am persuaded, based on conversations I've had with our city attorney, together with the amendments that Chair Melgar is going to introduce, that this legislation balances those priorities. I think this is an ordinance that will protect tenants without unintended consequence, so I support it as amended. I appreciate your leadership, Chair Melgar, for bringing it forward. [32:51] Speaker 1: Thank you so much. So colleagues, before I read the amendments and make a motion to those, first I would like to duplicate this file. There has been a request that we continue to work on both our city system for supporting folks and the language. And then I would like to make a motion to adopt the following amendments. So on page 3, line 4 through 6, and I do think that this addresses Mr. Erickson's building scenario, it will now— and this was proposed, I want to say thank you to Janann New at the Apartment Association. This language was agreed to by the tenants' groups. It will now read, the tenant is causing substantial damage to the rental unit or building, or is being so disorderly as to destroy the peace and quiet of others in the building or in adjacent buildings. So that amendment has been approved as to form by the city attorney. And so I'd like to make a motion that we amend the legislation and Move it forward. Oh, I'm sorry. To the to not next week because we don't have a mill. The next meeting of this committee will be the 30th. There you go. [34:24] Speaker 2: So I have it all as you've presented here. We will first have a duplicate made of the file. Then you're going to make a motion to amend the original file and then continue. continue that version as amended to November 30th. On those motions offered by the chair— [34:45] Speaker 1: Vice Chair Chen? [34:46] Speaker 4: Aye. [34:46] Speaker 8: Chen, aye. [34:47] Speaker 2: Member Dorsey? [34:48] Speaker 4: Aye. [34:48] Speaker 2: Dorsey, aye. Chair Melgar? [34:49] Speaker 4: Aye. [34:50] Speaker 2: Melgar, aye. Madam Chair, there are 3 ayes on those motions for the original file. [34:55] Speaker 1: Let's continue that to the call of the chair, please, the duplicated file. [35:00] Speaker 2: And then on the motion offered by the chair that the duplicated file be continued to the call of the chair. [35:06] Speaker 1: Vice Chair Chen. [35:08] Speaker 5: Aye. [35:08] Speaker 4: Chen, aye. [35:09] Speaker 2: Member Dorsey. [35:09] Speaker 4: Aye. [35:10] Speaker 2: Dorsey, aye. [35:10] Speaker 1: Chair Melgar. [35:11] Speaker 5: Aye. [35:12] Speaker 2: Melgar, aye. Madam Chair, there are 3 ayes on that motion. [35:14] Speaker 1: Thank you, and thank you to everyone in the community who came and, uh, supported this. Thank you. Um, let's go on to the next, uh, item, please. Number 2. [35:24] Speaker 2: Agenda item number 2 is a resolution adding the commemorative street name Anderson J.B. [35:29] Speaker 1: Williams Way to the 0 block of Peabody Street. This item is on our agenda as a potential committee report and may be sent for consideration by the Board of Supervisors on their agenda tomorrow, November 17th, 2026. Okay, thank you. We are now joined by District 10 Supervisor, uh, Shamon Walton, who is the sponsor. Um, the floor is yours. [35:48] Speaker 6: Thank you so much, Madam Chair, and thank you, colleagues. I am asking for your positive recommendation and support for this resolution to honor Anderson J.B. Williams by commemoratively naming the O Block of Peabody Street Anderson J.B. Williams Way. J.B. was a proud San Francisco native and a lifelong member of the Hunters Point community who dedicated decades of his life to serving, mentoring, and uplifting others. For more than 40 years, J.B. worked as a barber, building relationships, and earning the trust and respect of generations of District 10 residents. JB consistently invested in our youth, including providing free haircuts to students who maintain a 3.0 GPA and supporting young people as they celebrate milestones like graduations and proms. His commitment goes beyond barbering. He served as a mentor, role model, and father figure to countless young people, teaching the importance of self-respect, dignity, discipline, and personal responsibility. Let this be a reminder that his contributions matter, his legacy lives on, and the community he has helped shape will never forget him. I respectfully ask for your support and hope that you will move this forward to the full board as a committee report. [37:14] Speaker 1: Thank you, Supervisor. Uh, Supervisor Chen. Thank you, Chair Melga, and thank you, Supervisor Walton, for advancing this commemorative street name designation. In reading this resolution, I was very touched by the legacy of J.B. Williams and his barbershop on Leland Avenue in Visitation Valley. It is a place to build community, a trusted community gathering space where young people receive receive encouragement, guidance, and positive mentorship alongside a haircut. So please, Mr. Kurt, add me as a co-sponsor to this legislation. Thank you. [37:48] Speaker 7: Thank you. [37:49] Speaker 3: Thank you. [37:50] Speaker 1: Please, I'd like to be added as a co-sponsor as well. And thank you, Supervisor Walden, for doing this for the community and for, um, just the being able to recognize this story for generations going forward. Thank you. Um, let's go to public comment on this item, please. Thank you, Madam Chair. [38:08] Speaker 2: Land Use and Transportation will now hear public comment related to agenda item number 2. If you have public comment for this item, please come forward to the lectern at this time. And Madam Chair, it looks like we have no speakers for this item. [38:20] Speaker 1: Okay, public comment on this item is now closed. Um, I'd like to make a motion that we send this item out of committee to the full board with a positive recommendation and as a committee report. [38:31] Speaker 2: On the motion offered by the chair that this resolution be recommended to the Board of Supervisors as a committee report. [38:37] Speaker 1: Vice Chair Chen? [38:38] Speaker 2: Aye. Chen, aye. Member Dorsey? [38:39] Speaker 4: Aye. [38:40] Speaker 2: Dorsey, aye. Chair Melgar? [38:41] Speaker 5: Aye. [38:42] Speaker 2: Melgar, aye. Madam Chair, there are 3 ayes. [38:44] Speaker 1: Thank you, that motion passes. And let's go to item number 3, please. [38:49] Speaker 2: Agenda item number 3 is a resolution adding the commemorative street name Jace Young Way to the 1700 block of Yosemite Avenue. Like the previous item, this item is also on our agenda as potential committee report. It may be sent for consideration by the board tomorrow, November 17th. [39:01] Speaker 1: Okay, again, Supervisor Walden, the floor is yours. [39:04] Speaker 6: Thank you so much, Chair Melgar. Colleagues, I am also respectfully asking you for a positive recommendation and support for this resolution to honor the life and memory of Jace Young by commemoratively naming the 1700 block of Yosemite Avenue Jace Young Way. Jace was only 6 years old when his life was taken on July 4th, 2020, but the impact he made on his family and community will never be forgotten. He was a bright, joyful, and extraordinary young boy whose infectious smile, vibrant personality, and boundless curiosity touched everyone fortunate enough to know him. Known as a little gaming genius, Jace had a remarkable mind, a creative spirit, and an enthusiasm for life that brought happiness and laughter to his family, friends, and classmates. A commemorative street naming is more than just a sign. It is a permanent acknowledgment that Jace's life mattered and that his name will remain part of the fabric of our community. Our neighborhoods are built on the stories of people who live in them. Jace is part of the story of Bayview-Hunters Point, and we want our young people to know that their lives, their dreams, and their contributions matter. And I ask again that you approve this item and move it forward to the full board as a committee report. [40:36] Speaker 1: Thank you so much, uh, Supervisor. Supervisor Jorsey. [40:42] Speaker 2: Thank you, Chair Melgar. I was at the San Francisco Police Department when this tragedy unfolded, when I worked for Bill Scott, and I don't think there's a tragedy that affected us more. I really appreciate you bringing this forward. I'd like to be added as a co-sponsor and just again express my condolences to the family and loved ones of young Jace. This is an appropriate way to honor him. [41:11] Speaker 1: Supervisor Chen. Thank you, Chair Melga. Thank you again, Supervisor Walton, for advancing this resolution. I did not have the pleasure of meeting Jacey Young, and my heart and deepest condolence goes out to his loved ones. We will never know all the amazing things that life had in store for him. And I quote, that beloved 6-year-old child whose infectious smile, boundless curiosity, and vibrant spirit touched the lives of his family, friends, and classmates. This commemorative street destination can serve as a daily reminder of the everlasting spirit of young Jace to all those who will pass under its shadow. Thank you again, Mr. Clerk. [41:57] Speaker 2: I would also like to be added as a co-sponsor. [41:59] Speaker 1: Thank you. Thank you. [42:00] Speaker 4: Thank you. [42:02] Speaker 9: Thank you. [42:02] Speaker 1: And thank you, Supervisor, uh, Waldron. Um, this is, you know, heartbreak. And, um, please add me as a co-sponsor. We need to remember. Thank you. Um, let's go to public comment on this item, please. Thank you, Madam Chair. [42:22] Speaker 2: Land Use and Transportation will now hear public comment related to agenda item number 3, a commemorative street name for Jace Young Way for the 1700 block of Yosemite Avenue. If you have public comment for this item, please come forward to the lectern at this time. As a reminder, I will interrupt folks who provide public comments to an individual member. Please speak to the committee as a whole, and you may begin. Good afternoon. [42:47] Speaker 6: On behalf of Jace Young, I'm his father. [42:51] Speaker 10: I really appreciate this taking place. [42:56] Speaker 9: I hope that we can, you know, get this passed on behalf of him, on behalf of the family. [43:01] Speaker 1: It's really appreciated. [43:02] Speaker 2: I just want to say thank you. [43:03] Speaker 1: Thank you for your comments. Do we have anyone else who has public comment for agenda item number 3? [43:10] Speaker 2: Madam Chair? [43:19] Speaker 1: Public comment is now closed. I would like to make a motion that we send this out of the committee with a positive recommendation to the full board as a committee report. [43:30] Speaker 2: On the motion offered by the chair that this resolution be recommended as a committee report, Vice Chair Chen. [43:36] Speaker 5: Chen, aye. [43:36] Speaker 2: Member Dorsey. Dorsey, aye. Chair Melgar. [43:39] Speaker 5: Aye. [43:39] Speaker 4: Melgar, aye. [43:40] Speaker 2: Madam Chair, there are 3 ayes. [43:42] Speaker 1: Thank you. Thank you, Supervisor Walton. Thank you. Okay, um, Mr. Clerk, let's call items 4 and 5 together, please. [43:50] Speaker 2: Agenda item number 4 is a motion adopting the Planning Department's report on the interim zoning moratorium that prohibited data centers, uh, citywide for 45 days in accordance with California Government Code Section 65858. It also affirms the Planning Department's determination under CEQA and makes other appropriate findings. Agenda item number 5 is an urgency ordinance approving an extension of the interim zoning moratorium to prohibit data centers as defined citywide for 10 months and 15 days in accordance with that same code section. It also affirms the Planning Department's CEQA determination and makes other appropriate findings. Each of these items are on our agenda today as potential committee reports, and they may be sent for consideration by the Board of Supervisors tomorrow, November 17th, 2026. [44:36] Speaker 1: Thank you so much. We again— Supervisor Walden, thank you for this legislation. The floor is yours. [44:48] Speaker 6: Thank you so much, Chair Melgar, and again, thank you, colleagues. First, I want to just take the time to thank my colleagues for supporting the temporary moratorium on data centers, and I also want to thank Planning for their report. and for providing this response in such a short time period. After reading and reviewing Planning's report of the impacts of data centers in their 45-day data center moratorium report, it is clear that San Francisco does not completely understand the impacts of data centers in our communities. Furthermore, the following impacts or possible impacts in Planning's report leads us to understand that we do not fully know the negative consequences of data centers in community, and that more time is needed to truly learn and understand the possible harms. Issues of air quality, noise, water and wastewater, and electricity, to name a few, are still prevalent in the report from planning. The report indicates data centers can require substantial amounts of electricity, And may compete with housing, commercial development, electrification goals, and other users for limited transmission and distribution capacity. Their growth may also influence the timing, funding, and prioritization of future grid improvements. Data centers may affect water supplies and wastewater infrastructure through cooling systems, wastewater discharges, and indirect water consumption. Associated with power generation. Future impacts remain uncertain and depend on facility size, cooling technology, operating practices, and water supply conditions. Construction activities and backup diesel generators can contribute to regional and localized air quality impacts. Particular concerns include generator emissions compliance with permit requirements, cumulative pollution burdens, and potential impacts on environmental justice communities. Data centers can generate noise from mechanical equipment, cooling systems, and backup generator testing and operation. Concerns include both persistent tonal noise and intermittent generator noise, particularly in proximity to residential areas and other sensitive uses. Planning concluded in their methodology that the department notes that significant uncertainties remain regarding the scale and nature of potential future data center development in San Francisco, the characteristics of future facilities, and the cumulative demands such development could place on infrastructure systems. Planning also notes that The primary regulatory framework for data centers was adopted more than 2 decades ago, before the emergence of large-scale cloud computing and artificial intelligence applications. Additional analysis may be needed to determine whether existing definitions, review criteria, and reporting requirements fully capture the characteristics of new facility types. Second, while data centers are subject to extensive regulation, overnight is distributed— oversight is distributed across multiple agencies and levels of government. Understanding how these processes interact in practice may require additional coordination and analysis. Third, some aspects of the existing regulatory framework may warrant further study, including how current regulations apply to evolving facility types, how data center-related uses are distinguished from accessory computing functions within larger developments, and how existing regulations would apply in areas governed by specialized planning frameworks. These issues are discussed in greater detail in the appendices of the report. Finally, from planning, there remains substantial uncertainty regarding the scale, timing, and characteristics of any future data center development that could occur in San Francisco. Given these uncertainties, it may be premature to draw conclusions regarding whether additional local regulations would be warranted or what form they should take. In addition, the city needs to, of course, look at this as an initial assessment, not a complete evaluation. Significant questions remain unanswered, and additional technical analysis and interagency coordination are still needed. The city needs to evaluate whether data centers belong in San Francisco at all. The report focuses on how to regulate and accommodate future facilities without examining whether additional data center development should be prohibited at all. The city also needs to consider a permanent ban. Other cities have adopted prohibitions. San Francisco needs to evaluate this as a legitimate policy option rather than assume future development will be allowed. City should assess infrastructure capacity and impacts. The city lacks a complete inventory of existing facilities and does not know the exact total water demand of operating data centers. Electricity, water transmission capacity, and environmental impacts still remain unresolved. City needs to address existing compliance failures. The report identifies 5 active Air District notices of violation involving 200 Paul Avenue, including permit violations and operating limit exceedances. Cities should prioritize environmental justice. Communities already carrying disproportionate environmental burdens should not become default locations. The city must consider cumulative impacts and meaningful community input. The city must understand community benefits are not a substitute for policy agreements, impact Workforce commitments and local investments cannot resolve infrastructure constraints, eliminate diesel emissions or noise, or justify an inappropriate land use. And the absence of pending applications is not a reason to let the moratorium expire. The city must proactively evaluate future development and its potential impacts. [51:37] Speaker 4: Thank you. [51:38] Speaker 6: This is definitely not an attack on tech, but we do have to answer the question how San Francisco can consider accommodating additional data centers when existing facilities have unresolved compliance and enforcement issues, especially in communities already facing disproportionate environmental burdens. We also want to highlight that other cities and jurisdictions have taken a moratorium or some type of moratorium extension action. Temporary moratoriums in Oakland, Richmond, Hayward, Gilroy, and Oakland, as identified in the report. Zoning standards in Benicia, regulatory studies in Santa Clara, proposed development standards in San Jose, a permanent prohibition in Monterey Park, just to name a few. [52:30] Speaker 4: Thank you. [52:30] Speaker 6: And Oakland and Oklahoma City have extended their moratoriums, while Boise, Idaho already has a 6-month moratorium in place, and cities in New York and South Carolina have data center moratoriums for 12 months. This is why we are requesting a moratorium extension for 10 months and 15 days as a committee report, and also we want to make a motion to accept the Planning report as a committee report as well. And I know we have some folks here from Planning, so I would just love for them to provide their thoughts on the report and just give an update to this committee on what they found. [53:12] Speaker 1: Welcome, Ms. Gibson. Good afternoon, Chair Melgar and members of the committee and Supervisor Walton. I'm Lisa Gibson, the Environmental Review Officer with the Planning Department. Thank you for the opportunity to provide some remarks about the report that the Planning Department prepared regarding data center land use and environmental considerations. Supervisor Walton provided a very thorough and, and to my mind, accurate characterization of the report's approach and conclusions, the key considerations. The report was prepared in response to direction from the mayor's office and the requirements of the board's 45-day moratorium on data center development. Given the short timeframe, the report is an initial assessment rather than a comprehensive study. The department focused on identifying key issues, reviewing the existing regulatory framework, consulting with partner agencies, and examining approaches being considered in other jurisdictions. I won't repeat the report's issues, the environmental issues and the infrastructure planning-related concerns, but indeed we did identify that there are issues presented by data centers and uncertainties, and that at the same time we do have experience in San Francisco with reviewing and permitting data centers. We have at this time a limited number in, in the city, and we don't have any active applications pending for any new standalone data centers. And as to wrap up here, just want to note that the report, of course, doesn't recommend any particular policy outcome, such as whether the moratorium should be extended or whether permanent controls should be adopted. Instead, it identifies issues that may warrant further evaluation and outlines potential policy approaches that policymakers such as yourselves could consider if they determine that additional action is warranted. And this report does fulfill the department's work to provide information and analysis to inform the Board's deliberations. My colleague Josh Pollack and I are available if you have any questions. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Gibson. Did you have further comments, Supervisor Walton? Not right now. Okay. I was just going to say I read your report when it was hot off the presses, and notwithstanding the things that we don't know, and you acknowledge there are things that we don't know, I thought it was a very good report. I thought it was thorough and conducive to the policymakers making decisions right now, which we must. And I will say, you know, it's difficult for regulators or legislative bodies to keep up with the innovations and evolutions of technology, which happen usually faster than we can catch up. I do think it's totally appropriate, and I'm grateful, Supervisor Walton, that you stepped into this discussion swiftly to just take a breather and see see how things develop, knowing that the demands on our infrastructure and, you know, our very valuable 7x7, you know, could be important and significant. And so I just wanted to say thank you so much for the thoroughness of your work, and it's much appreciated. Supervisor Chen. Thank you, Chair Mauga. I also want to echo and again thank Supervisor Walton for his leadership on this very important legislation. I also had an opportunity to review the 45-day data center moratorium report, and the analysis highlights the data centers presented a wide range of very complex and also interrelated planning issues and challenges. This including the capacity of our current electricity infrastructure. And this is really important. We have multiple lessons learned in less than a year, environmental impact that related to water and air quality and competing land use needs, and also workforce impact, environmental justice, and long-term citywide growth objectives. And the issues of environmental justice is also particularly important to me. Currently, all 3 of our city's facilities are located within environmental justice communities. And that, in addition to their existing burdens, that also means they have to grapple with many of the additional impacts associated with the data centers, including air quality, noises, energy infrastructures, and industrial land use. Without stronger regulation, our local communities ending up funding these causes. So, I believe there is a strong rationale for this legislation given the complexity of planning issues and also the interagency coordination that is needed to develop permanent regulatory changes. So this is why I'm also in support of the extension of the original 45-day moratorium to 10 months and 15 days. Again, I want to thank Supervisor Walton again for your leadership. [58:44] Speaker 3: Thank you. [58:47] Speaker 1: Thank you. With that, let's go to public comment on this item, please, Mr. Clerk. Well, thank you, Madam Chair. [58:53] Speaker 2: Land Use and Transportation will now hear public comment related to agenda item numbers 4 and 5, which are called together. Members of the public who wish to speak on these items should line up to speak along that right-hand side of this room. Each speaker will have 2 minutes. [59:06] Speaker 1: There will be a soft chime when you have 30 seconds remaining, and, and then there will be a louder chime when your time has expired. [59:12] Speaker 2: As I've mentioned a few times already at today's meeting, the board currently has a rule that addresses disorderly public comment to prohibit speakers from addressing a member of the committee directly, regardless of whether they are in support or not in support of the particular supervisor or their policies. [59:28] Speaker 5: Would— [59:29] Speaker 2: that also includes thanking a supervisor directly. Please do not say thank you to any supervisor or address them directly. Speak to the committee as a whole and We have a speaker ready to provide their comments. [59:39] Speaker 1: I'll start your time once you begin. [59:40] Speaker 2: Hello, my name is Glenn Rogers, landscape architect. Today I would like to bring to your attention the concentration of data centers along Paul Avenue spanning an area 3 blocks long and 3 blocks wide. These facilities are located directly adjacent to schools and parks. And sit only 60 feet away from residential homes. Noise generated by these facilities has been measured at 80 decibels, a level capable of causing hearing loss and contributing to mental illness. Because the data centers have been permitted via conditional use permits, their exact total number is unclear, but it is estimated that 12 to 15 data centers are currently operating in the Bayview. Some data centers utilize diesel engines to obscure their heavy electricity consumption. Furthermore, it appears that Bayview residents are effectively subsidizing the massive power usage required by these facilities. I am requesting the implementation of comprehensive monitoring for data centers in the Bayview. This monitoring program should track Publicly subsidized electricity costs, noise output levels, air pollution and emissions, heat generated by the facilities, tax relief and incentives provided to data centers by the city. Additionally, we ask the data centers be held to strict standards of operational transparency, including mandatory disclosures of information upon request. Therefore, we are formally requesting a moratorium of new data centers approvals until these monitoring and transparency requirements have been fully established. Thank you for your comments. To the next speaker, please. Hello, my name is Jazzy. [61:51] Speaker 8: So good. [61:51] Speaker 2: I'm here to talk about the extension of the data center moratorium. [61:56] Speaker 1: I think it's especially important for us to extend it and keep it going because there's a lot we do not know. And in the report, I read that data centers can be used for telecommunication, computing cloud services, and there's a lot that we don't know right now, right? [62:13] Speaker 2: So this past week, there was a lot of planes grounded because of telecommunication problems. [62:19] Speaker 1: which DNA centers are involved with holding that information. And then as well as Microsoft Outlook outage, that is a computing cloud service. And so with that, the data centers are housing this. So I think there should be more research involved because it involves a lot of our daily activities. I also want to highlight the fact that 2 of the 3 data centers in San Francisco are within Bayview. [62:47] Speaker 2: And so that's taking up a lot of space and around schools, as the previous speaker just talked about. And in hearing the names, the street names proposed for Bayview, I think that spaces in Bayview could have a better purpose than to serve data centers. [63:07] Speaker 1: Learning about the child today who died too early, I learned about him today, and I think that there should be more done to learn about people in our community and not serve spaces for these data centers. And so I encourage more research into all the uses of them and what that land use could be used for otherwise. Thank you. [63:30] Speaker 2: Thank you for coming. Let's have the next speaker, please. Hello, my name is Connie Jung Mills. [63:39] Speaker 1: I'm a San Francisco resident and a member of Indivisible SF. [63:43] Speaker 2: All across the country, people are saying no to data centers. [63:47] Speaker 1: A growing list of cities have placed long-term moratoriums on the building of new data centers, and San Francisco should join that list. Data centers increase noise and air pollution. They consume vast amounts of water. They drain energy from what's needed to run vital services in our city. Additional data centers will push our power grid, grid well beyond its limit, resulting in power outages and public transit breakdowns. Residents will end up paying the price for this expansion, and our utility bills will skyrocket. The planning department estimates that a single 50-megawatt data center could consume as much energy as 25,000 homes. This is a perfect example of how billionaires and corporations assert their priorities over the needs of the residents in this city. [64:38] Speaker 2: I urge you to extend the moratorium or pass a permanent ban on the building of new data centers in San Francisco and make a firm commitment to prioritize public needs over resource-intensive AI. Thank you very much. [64:52] Speaker 1: Thank you for your comments. [64:53] Speaker 2: Let's have the next speaker, please. [64:58] Speaker 1: Dr. Ahimsa Porter-Sumchai, founder, CEO, and principal investigator of the Hunters Point Biomonitoring Foundation. I've submitted to you and published the preliminary recommendation that we have for the design of a comprehensive AI data center monitoring program that is inclusive of human biomonitoring, environmental monitoring for water usage, toxic emissions, soil contamination, noise, and thermal footprint. I wanted to begin by challenging the statement that there are 3 AI data centers in San Francisco. There are 2 AI data archives that identify up to 15 AI data centers in San Francisco. I know there's a lot of confusion about definitions. What is occurring on Paul Avenue is the co-location of 6 AI data centers in 200 Paul Avenue, Digital Realty at 300, and at 400 Paul Avenue you have Anova. What is not known is the power demand for this facility. I believe it could be up to 150 megawatts. And AI-assisted analysis has concluded that it's at least 72 megawatts. So I think that it's important that we identify the power load and that we identify separate rate categories for these high-load consumers so that a community with an area median income of $35,000 to $55,000 is not subsidizing a facility of this energy capacity. Also, many of you are aware that there are laws calling for mandatory disclosure. Thank you for sharing your comments with the committee. [67:04] Speaker 2: Let's have the next speaker, please. Hi, my name is Mark Schlossberg. I'm a managing director at Food and Water Watch, a national environmental organization that works at the intersection of food, water, and climate justice. With thousands of members and supporters across San Francisco. Thank you so much for bringing forward the moratorium on data centers and this proposed extension, which we fully support. People across the country are outraged about the growth of data centers. It's really quite something how, how quickly it's been rolled out with little to no regulation or planning. And it's no wonder that people are outraged. Data centers, the AI data centers, have been shown to increase electricity rates, draw huge amounts of water, create tremendous amount of noise, the equivalent of a lawnmower going 24 hours a day at your house. They've been shown to cause localized air pollution and many, many other problems. And for all these problems, for all these costs, what are we being asked to give? What's the trade-off? Well, the leading— some of the leading AI companies, the executives are saying that the purpose is to eliminate jobs. [68:13] Speaker 3: to eliminate large swaths of jobs, and that there's a non-zero chance that it's going to wipe out humanity. [68:19] Speaker 2: This does not seem like a good deal for us to be making here. At the very least, it requires a moratorium. We had an election a couple of weeks ago, and candidates for governor in Texas, Georgia, Kansas, and elsewhere ran on platforms of instituting moratoriums on data centers. [68:38] Speaker 3: If they can do it in Texas, Georgia, Kansas, and elsewhere across this country. We can do it here in California, and we can do it here in San Francisco. I thank you very much for bringing forward this measure, and we strongly support the extension of the moratorium on data centers. [68:50] Speaker 2: Thanks. Thank you for your comments. The next speaker, please. [68:52] Speaker 1: Hello, my name is Sarai. I'm a tech worker in AI, and I'm here to ask you to extend the moratorium and turn it into a full permanent ban across the whole city. [69:02] Speaker 3: The problem with AI is actually who owns it. Under the billionaires, AI is trained on our collective knowledge and labor. [69:07] Speaker 1: They reap the wealth, but it's our livelihood that is destroyed. [69:10] Speaker 3: 14,000 Bay Area tech workers got laid off this year, almost double the year before, and SF has already lost 47,000 jobs overall. And the data centers, they don't even bring new jobs here either. I've been inside data center many times, and throughout the whole day, I was lucky to even see 5 people. [69:25] Speaker 2: The people— [69:26] Speaker 3: the city's report also admitted this. [69:29] Speaker 2: Also, the Dogpatch site will push out a crane and heavy hauling business that would— [69:32] Speaker 3: that already employs working people. in true blue-collar jobs. [69:35] Speaker 1: Finally, the working— the wealth created by AI should belong to the people who actually made it. [69:41] Speaker 3: OpenAI and Anthropic alone are valued at trillions, enough to pay our entire city's budget of $17 billion 120 times over. The money belongs to us in housing, in transit, schools, and healthcare. [69:54] Speaker 1: And AI should be used to shorten our work week, not to replace us. This is why we need a full permanent ban, and that is one step toward pushing the power back into our hands. [70:03] Speaker 3: Thank you. [70:04] Speaker 2: Thank you for coming. [70:05] Speaker 1: Let's have the next speaker, please. Good afternoon. My name is Olivia, and I'm a resident of District 8. At a time when working people in San Francisco are struggling more than ever, with evictions and rents skyrocketing more than every other major city in America, we are now considering opening our doors to data centers being built in our city. All for a technology evaluated by our markets to be worth trillions on the sole promise of replacing working people for cheap. All for a technology built upon the collective labors of the human race as a whole, but without our collective consent. All for a technology that has only served to enrich those few who stole that collective knowledge and passed it off as theirs. Despite their overwhelming unpopularity, thousands of data centers have been built across the country in the last decade. With the United States hosting half of all data centers globally, 10 times more data centers than the next country on the list. These data centers wreak havoc on our environment, poison our most vulnerable communities, and put enormous strain on our energy infrastructure, all while ordinary people suffer the brunt of escalating climate disasters caused by climate change. Any level of scrutiny reveals that this so-called technological miracle of artificial intelligence is built on the backs of the many who absorb its most devastating costs but reap none of its benefits. It is one of the greatest threats to working people today and continues to cause immeasurable harm to the people of San Francisco, the birthplace of this technology. The people of San Francisco do not want data centers in our city, not now and not ever. A temporary moratorium is not enough. We are calling for a permanent ban on data centers being built in our city. For all of you here, come out outside the City Hall on Friday at 4 PM to advocate for no data centers in San Francisco. [71:53] Speaker 4: Thank you. [71:53] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. Please, just before we go on, folks, there is a board rule, I believe it's 1.3.1, that prohibits your applause in the chamber. If you have support that you want to express for a speaker, you can throw your hands up and we can see you, but we do need to keep the meeting flowing. So let's have the next speaker begin. [72:16] Speaker 1: Hi, I'm Priyana with the Party for Socialism and Liberation, and I organize in Bayview-Hunters Point, where there are already 2 of the major data center sites in our city. And the Black and brown communities are, as always, are made to pay the biggest price, where asthma is already 10 times higher than elsewhere in the city. And yet the Nova campus there is planning to expand to over 36 megawatts. Under the requirement that would require a CEQA review. And even more so, as Dr. Sumshai just said, and this was paused by the moratorium for now, using diesel generators, which are a known carcinogen with no limits in an emergency that operators get to define. And the report, it incorrectly assumes and presumes that AI data centers here are inevitable, but they are not. It's not a question of where and how. This is a political question about who gets to make decisions in our city. So will you listen to lobbyists and billionaires or the people? In 45 days, where were the town halls or even a call for public comment today? Well, now you get to choose, and we say no. It's bipartisan, where over 73% of California and the U.S. [73:29] Speaker 2: say no more data centers in our communities. [73:32] Speaker 1: 63% worry about the environment, and concern is highest in the Bay Area. Our No Data Center campaign thus far has blocked over 173 data centers nationally. The people are powerful. And if you're ready to organize, if you're hearing this and you're ready to fight, join our No Data Center campaign. We have organizing meetings every week. We have a rally this Friday at 4:00 PM, and come talk to one of us afterwards. [73:58] Speaker 2: Thank you. [73:59] Speaker 1: We need an extension. We need a full ban. And we need environmental reparations for Bayview-Hunters Point. Just the extension is not enough. You need to consider this and pass the motion tomorrow to the Board of Supervisors. We say no more data centers in our city. We say power to the people and not the billionaires. Is that right? Speaker's time has concluded. Thank you for your comments. [74:21] Speaker 2: Let's have the next speaker, please. Good afternoon. [74:26] Speaker 1: My name is Kira Tang, and I'm a representative from Green Action voicing our support for a permanent ban on mega AI data centers in San Francisco. AI data centers will expedite the issues of global warming through their large consumption of water and energy to operate, and these activities will increase— [74:43] Speaker 6: will lead to increases in air pollution and sea level rise. [74:47] Speaker 2: Public health issues are due to increase with the rise of large AI data centers. [74:51] Speaker 6: From constant noise pollution levels of 85 decibels or more, leading to auditory issues and stress-related health issues, to emitting toxic particulate matter into the air, leading to increases in respiratory illnesses. [75:03] Speaker 2: Many of the proposed data centers are located in key environmental justice communities such as Bayview's Hunters Point and Mission's Bay, who are already overburdened by increased industrial pollution and toxic waste sites compared to other parts of the cities. [75:15] Speaker 6: As the cost of the living crisis in San Francisco has gotten exponentially worse, the water and energy usage from mega AI data centers will cause for a strain on city resources, making utilities skyrocket for residents and not AI companies. [75:28] Speaker 2: Additionally, we join residents of Bayview-Hunters Point urging for increased transparency regarding the AI data center campus on 200 Paul Avenue, such as their current water and energy usage and consumption and their emission rates, as well as a increasing transparency regarding all mega AI data centers in San Francisco. [75:48] Speaker 9: Thank you. [75:48] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. Let's have the next speaker, please. Hi, my name is Elliot Hellman. I'm a member of 350 San Francisco. I live in District 6 in Mission Bay. I want to thank Supervisor Walton for leading on this issue. You can't thank an individual member of the committee. [76:11] Speaker 4: What? [76:12] Speaker 1: Please direct your comments to the full panel of folks that are impaled presently. Thank you. [76:17] Speaker 5: I am. [76:20] Speaker 2: Most of us here are relieved with the results of the midterm elections, and we're not going to get those texts anymore asking for donations every 2 minutes. And while we're hearing that, along with affordability, fighting AI and data centers were high on voters' minds. We also know that fighting corruption was an issue that drove people to the polls. While I think 10 months and 15 days is vastly insufficient for the city to undergo a full review, I would ask you to also fight corruption and vote yes on this moratorium for all the reasons that other people have brought up here today, but also to fight back against the corruption of our local and national politics. that the tech billionaires and oligarchs behind these data centers engender. I want to also repeat what Supervisor Walton stated earlier. Maybe we should evaluate whether or not a data center should be sited in San Francisco at all. [77:19] Speaker 1: Thanks. Thank you so much for your comments. Let's have the next speaker, please. [77:22] Speaker 2: Hello, supervisors. My name is Peter Belden, and I'm the political chair of the Sierra Club in San Francisco and also a District 10 resident. Without naming them, I want to thank all the supervisors that have supported this ordinance. The Sierra Club strongly supports this 10-month pause. I also want to recognize the excellent report that was done by the planning department, and I want to encourage all the committee members to read the letter that the Sierra Club submitted in advance of the committee meeting in support of this ordinance. I think this is a really important topic. It's an important vote, and I encourage all the members of the committee and all the members of the board. tomorrow as well to vote in support of this pause. [78:02] Speaker 3: Thank you. [78:02] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. [78:03] Speaker 1: Next speaker, please. [78:04] Speaker 2: Good afternoon. My name is Ishwar, and I'm a resident of District 8. I want to start with my observations of the 45-day moratorium report. The report explains the electrical limitations and environmental concerns. However, it lacks direct input from communities, and there have been no attempts to gather public concerns and sentiment. The report admits to only being an initial assessment and not enough. and also skirts over the question of whether we should even have data centers in the city. Given the effects of the AI boom on the housing crisis and rent emergency, it is clear that the progression of AI and data centers is going starkly against the will of the people, including the use of AI software by ICE to target and terrorize our civilians. Nationwide, the people are pushing for permanent data center bans, and San Francisco should be no different. The current framework and zoning rules for data centers are out of date and designed to bypass public opinion, leaving our communities in the dark on where and when data centers are being built. I'm part of the No Data Centers movement devoted for fighting for power over the decisions that affect our lives, and I will also be joining the public rally this Friday to show and vocalize opposition to the construction of data centers. And I invite those in attendance today to make your voice be heard through both public comment and demonstration. It is abundantly clear from polling that public sentiment heavily opposes data centers, with over 70% opposition nationwide and opposition levels increasing further over the last few months. With such strong public opposition, I'm recommending the extension and urge a further permanent ban to the board and commit to passing them. [79:39] Speaker 1: Thank you. [79:40] Speaker 2: Thank you so much for your comments. To the next speaker, please. [79:46] Speaker 9: Good afternoon. [79:47] Speaker 2: My name is Jacob. I'm a Tenderloin resident who's been organizing for some time now within my neighborhood and throughout the city to inform its inhabitants of the threats of new data centers and the costs of those already here. I urge this committee, committee to move this report to refer to the full board tomorrow. The Board of Supervisors must be as informed as their constituents. [80:05] Speaker 3: Thank you. [80:06] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. [80:07] Speaker 1: Next speaker, please. Hello, I'm a resident of D6. I live in SoMa and also on Market Street. Um, there is one confirmed data center, I believe, in SoMa. And just about data centers in general, in 2025, reports linked to Amazon data center to miscarriages and rare cancers, drawing concerns from data centers' presence in Central Ohio. [80:32] Speaker 3: Caltech researchers found data centers' air pollutants are expected to contribute to 1,300 premature deaths every year in the U.S. [80:38] Speaker 1: by 2030. Research future data centers can significantly degrade air quality, creating a public health burden on top of, of up to $20 billion the next 2 years. If you have family members with asthma or other health conditions, the air pollution from these data centers could be affecting them right now. It's a public health issue we need to address urgently. The Amazon data center part's interesting because I hear rumors that there is a planned Amazon data center that's going to happen on 7th Street. I can't get any information or transparency on that, but that is an issue I have as a resident. I'm reading about how maybe the downtown mall is going to be turned into a data center. I live a few blocks from that, so that is also a very personal issue for me as well. And then I've also been reading about how our mayor has this Office of Innovation that another former mayor, billionaire Michael Bloomberg, donated $7 million to, to, I don't know, get us all on board even more with tech and AI and how to use that here. It kind of feels like a conflict of interest to have billionaires in New York donating money to billionaires running SF here to get us even more entrenched in AI when the people here are saying, can you think about our health? Can you think about us? [81:52] Speaker 3: Can we put a pause on all this data center AI stuff and put people before profits? [81:57] Speaker 1: Like now, and I'm also in solidarity with the people in the Philippines fighting against Paxilica. Thank you for comments. So the next speaker, please. Ann Colachitas. The San Francisco Gray Panthers strongly supports this this extension, and we'd like to set a goal of a full and permanent ban. But, you know, already this is a public health crisis, and we're wondering why the Health Department is not working on this right now. You know, we have already burdened communities that are getting these data centers, and we really need to find out what are the impacts and how to protect all the citizens of San Francisco. Francisco from this proliferation. Thank you. Thank you for your comments. Let's have the next speaker, please. [82:56] Speaker 2: John Anderson, resident of District 2, member of 350SF, supporting the extension of the data center moratorium. At a minimum, it's clear that more time is needed to get a system that would allow the environmental and— marginal environmental and energy costs to be directed directly to the data centers rather than borne by the ratepaying public as a whole, similar to the one that Dr. Sumchai mentioned. And I just want to say without thanking anybody that I was impressed by her comments. And I'm worried that someone with the expertise of Dr. Semchai was trying to shoehorn her comments into a 2-minute public comment period and not giving it as a witness. So I hope you will fix that before it goes before the board. [84:09] Speaker 4: Thank you. [84:10] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. [84:11] Speaker 1: Let's have the next speaker, please. Hello, my name is Ronnie Diamant Wilson. I am a member of the 1,000 Grandmothers Bayview Hunters Point Working Group and a member also of District 9. Data centers, especially large facilities built to support cloud computing and AI, create major challenges for local communities, energy grids, and the environment. Problems include energy grid overload and rising bills, including massive power demand, spiking electricity costs, fossil fuels reliance, and then also water scarcity and infrastructure strain. including high water consumption and local system pressures. Air and noise pollution, including backup generators and turbines, health disparities, and constant noise. Heat islands, including waste heat. And finally, uneven economic benefits, low job creation, and land monopoly. San Francisco does not officially track data centers under a dedicated land use category, with city estimates and industry directories varying from 5 to 16. Detailed regional audits and directory listings track 12 distinct street addresses within the city including operational sites and permitted projects, while the broader San Francisco Bay Area contains over 170 facilities. The discrepancy itself raises a basic question: does San Francisco have a clear accounting of the scale or data center operations concentrated in the neighborhood? If San Francisco intends to become the nation's AI capital, it should also become— Excuse me, Councilmember Herbold. the national model for monitoring consequences. Thank you. [86:25] Speaker 6: Thank you so much. [86:26] Speaker 2: Let's have the next speaker, please. [86:27] Speaker 5: Hello, committee. [86:33] Speaker 2: I'm here to speak in support of the data centers moratorium and to urge a permanent ban on data centers. It's obvious to San Franciscans that data centers are not a good use of land use. They take up a ton of space, electricity, and provide almost no jobs. long-term jobs. So why is this even a question? Data centers are a perfect example of our society which allocates resources based on maximal profit incentive instead of the needs of the people. These data centers are so profitable that they crowd out investments in things that San Franciscans actually need, such as housing, transit, childcare, healthcare, and much more. While challenging the underlying economic system that enables such nonsensical land use, May not be in the purview of this committee. The minimum that we must do is a permanent ban on data centers in San Francisco. Thank you. Thank you for your comments. [87:26] Speaker 1: To the next speaker, please. [87:31] Speaker 2: Good afternoon, Supervisor Zach Weisenberger with Young Community Developers. I'm here to urge you to extend the moratorium on new data centers. Planning's report makes clear that the city is not prepared to make long-term decisions about these facilities. The city relies on an outdated framework from 2002, and Planning's report identifies major information gaps, leaving fundamental questions unanswered. Although this is a citywide moratorium, communities that have long carried disproportionate environmental burdens will once again be asked to absorb the impacts of these intensive uses. In Bayview, these concerns are not hypothetical. The report identifies 5 active Air District notices of violation associated with the data center at 200 Paul. How can we consider additional facilities when we haven't demonstrated we can effectively regulate existing ones? On average, Bayview residents live 9 years less than other San Franciscans. We cannot evaluate proposals in isolation or ignore how additional facilities compound existing burdens. We must also consider what we're giving up. Much of our city's industrial land supports small businesses and working-class jobs. Data centers occupy substantial land while generating few permanent jobs. What businesses and economic opportunities will be displaced? More broadly, why does this infrastructure need to be located in San Francisco? Most AI workloads do not require proximity to users. Why dedicate our limited valuable land to uses that could be located elsewhere? We are facing a severe housing crisis, and our limited land and resources should prioritize affordable housing, accessible jobs, and infrastructure that serves our communities. Data centers compete with housing for electricity, infrastructure, construction materials, and labor. We must consider whether dedicating scarce resources to data centers serves the long-term interests of residents. Finally, Planning's report focuses almost exclusively on accommodating data centers without meaningfully evaluating a complete prohibition as a legitimate policy option, despite other jurisdictions having adopted such prohibitions. This vote has generational implications and will forever be part of your legislative records. I urge you to extend the moratorium and put our communities first. [89:25] Speaker 10: Thank you. [89:25] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. To the next speaker, please. Good afternoon, supervisors. Richard Ivanhoe, and I support extending the moratorium on data centers. There have been a lot of good comments already. Just wondering how many here were around last December when there was an almost citywide power outage. City College lost power last week. Data centers use a lot of electricity. We are going to look at many more power outages unless we come up with some way to prevent them. Data centers also need a lot of water. We don't know if we're going to eventually get into a water shortage as well. So I think these need to be studied, and I think there needs to be a moratorium until we know more. Thank you. Thank you for your comments. So the next speaker, please. Good afternoon, supervisors. Joseph Smook with the Race and Equity in All Planning Coalition. Rep SF fully supports the extension of the data center moratorium. Artificial intelligence, like other technologies, may have potential to improve people's lives. However, the approach taken by large AI firms is reckless and potentially devastating for people's livelihoods. Data centers required by the major AI firms do not support the development of a beneficial AI. Rather, they are simply hyperscaling for the sake of their own profits and their own power. and the race to achieve a theoretical end goal of artificial general intelligence, which will only serve to centralize power with the corporation that gets there first. Our communities must not pay the price for their arrogant and reckless pursuit of limitless profit and power. Baby Hunters Point, Potrero Hill, some of Mission residents have suffered disproportionate environmental burdens for generations. Environmental justice referenced in planning's report is not just about changing the geography of harms. It's about putting communities at the forefront of making decisions for their future. Technological advancement must serve communities. It's imperative these 10 months be granted along with a genuine, inclusive process that engages communities most harmed by industrial pollution. Tech companies are notoriously secretive about their data centers' impacts on power and water consumption, noise and pollution. The city must demand that third-party audited data be provided with general— with— be provided to the general public. We demand the moratorium be extended and the city commit to a comprehensive, transparent, and community-centered evaluation without assuming the data centers will ultimately be permitted. The staff report recommends a set of next steps, but none of those include consultation with organizations that work directly with people most impacted by environmental issues. This must include Baby Hunters Point, Potrero Hill, SoMa, Mission, and Treasure Island at the very least. The possibility of a permanent ban should always be on the table throughout the 10-month process. Thank you. Thank you for your comments. The next speaker, please. [92:51] Speaker 1: My name is Catherine Vellan. I'm a long-term resident of San Francisco. And I'm not speaking as a scientist. [93:05] Speaker 3: I'm speaking as a person who follows the news. [93:09] Speaker 1: Observes what's happening in our community, and I'm just horrified. There's this big race, apparently, clearly there's this big race by these billionaire tech people to just push this stuff through, and we're all like trying to keep up with what's in today's news about, you know, okay, you know, a threat to humanity, the extreme drains on our resources, um, to our environment threats, and also to our communities. And it certainly doesn't— um, I don't miss the point that there are these centers in, uh, Bayview-Hunters Point and communities where over and over, um, things get dumped there. So let's think about the people, not the billionaires. Let's take San Francisco back. And, um, yeah, let's have the moratorium and just build up all a nice support and all the information we need to just keep these things, get their foot back out of the door of San Francisco and this country, take our city back, take our country back, and get these greedy, profit-driven, crazy billionaires out of our lives. [94:27] Speaker 5: Thank you. [94:27] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. Let's have the next speaker, please. Good afternoon, supervisors. My name is Mitch Mandkin. I'm here representing San Francisco Housing Development Corporation. [94:40] Speaker 3: We build affordable housing, we provide resident services, financial counseling, and entrepreneurship training, and we work citywide but especially in the Black community and the Bayview and the Fillmore neighborhoods. [94:50] Speaker 2: I'm here to support the proposed 10-month and 15-day extension of the data center moratorium. We need to understand the impacts of these data centers better, including having a clear accounting of the data centers that already exist and clear identification of any future proposed data centers, since we don't already have a classification in our code of it. Potential impacts include strain on electrical grid emissions and noise, as you heard earlier. And given those serious potential impacts, the report prepared during the moratorium should analyze prohibition of data centers as a policy option. A citywide moratorium. But we should recognize that the biggest impacts of these data centers are going to hit neighborhoods like the Bayview that have more industrial land and residential areas that are near industrial areas. [95:33] Speaker 3: That industrial land is scarce, and it's needed for uses that create good-paying, long-term jobs for people living in the neighborhood. [95:40] Speaker 2: The voice of the residents of our community must be heard as part of future actions that are related to data centers. Thank you so much for bringing forward this legislation and this item. Thank you for comments. Next speaker, please. [95:50] Speaker 1: Good afternoon, Supervisors. [95:56] Speaker 2: Zachary Frial, D5 resident, Somcan. [95:59] Speaker 1: In their initial assessment, planning staff raised several concerns about data centers competing with housing development and electrification goals. For one, San Francisco has over 70,000 units of housing in the pipeline, the infrastructure demands of which may compete with the intensive electricity, water, and wastewater needs of data centers. Additionally, earlier this month, the Bay Area Air District recently passed rules banning the sale of gas water— [96:23] Speaker 2: gas-powered water heaters in an effort to decarbonize and electrify housing in SF and across the Bay Area, which will require additional electrical capacity. These competing goals must be comprehensively analyzed in relation to the tremendous strain that new data centers will put on San Francisco's infrastructural capacity, and a full range of policy options, including a permanent ban should be considered in the subsequent assessment. As such, more time is needed for the city to fully evaluate the potential impacts of data centers, which is why we support an extension of the moratorium. During this time, planning and the other city departments should take great care in consulting with environmental justice communities like the Bayview, SoMa, Potrero, and Mission, who are likely to bear the majority of impacts from new data centers. [97:06] Speaker 9: Thank you. [97:07] Speaker 2: Thank you for next— [97:09] Speaker 1: thank you for your comments. [97:10] Speaker 2: Let's have the next speaker, please. Good afternoon, supervisors. Peter Papadopoulos speaking today with the United Save the Mission Coalition. So I want to thank the sponsors of the legislation and also the planning department for your report. It was very helpful to understanding the situation as we currently know it, which is we're hearing is incomplete. More incomplete, we feel in the big picture, is that 20 years ago when this zoning, these definitions were created. We did not have any idea where we were headed. We did not anticipate these uses. And to remind us all that these zonings in particular are critical blue-collar job space protectors. These are significant amounts of jobs, good-paying jobs in these communities of color. And they were negotiated over multi-year processes in the Eastern Neighborhoods Plans with these communities. So they need to be evaluated in that context. There are also, as you've been hearing, the significant environmental concerns that we want to weigh in here into this picture. So there's really a whole bunch of areas that we feel need to be addressed looking forward. These are also neighborhoods with higher unemployment, and again, these are some of the best-paying job spaces. So it makes sense to just take a big picture look at all this, we think. I mean, just practically speaking. As a business person, a chocolatier, a custom furniture shop—these are the kind of things that are going to, that are being displaced and will be displaced, and they just can't compete for price. [98:42] Speaker 5: Right? [98:42] Speaker 2: These are rounding errors to these companies, these five million dollar buildings. So, weighing whether the definitions are still correct and appropriate makes sense to us. Going on to explore some of the many questions that the planning department raised, and in the meantime, extending the moratorium, we think, is a thoughtful. [99:00] Speaker 1: next step. [99:01] Speaker 2: It's not anti-tech, it's, it's constructive San Francisco, we feel, to take this step. [99:06] Speaker 5: Thank you. [99:06] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. [99:08] Speaker 1: Let's have the next speaker, please. [99:08] Speaker 2: Good afternoon, supervisors. Peter Warfield, head of Library Users Association, libraryusers2004@protonmail.com and PO Box 170544. San Francisco, California 94117-0544. I'd like to thank the supervisors very much for proposing these moratoria for all the reasons that they've said and for many of the reasons, if not all of the ones, that have been previously mentioned by many of the folks who've spoken here. My first question is, for what? What is the use of these data centers? What are they being used for? Is that for a technology which the heads of companies themselves have said could be the end of democracy or the end of humanity? Is that so that AI can help custom create detailed plans for teenagers to kill themselves? There have been some lawsuits. There have been some findings. 47 attorney generals have— there's a whole range of information that leaks out piece by piece. There's not been certainly any full disclosure from the corporations about the downsides of this technology or the data centers in particular. Much is not yet known. Much will become known. Just as an example, there was a very recent article in the New York Times about jet plane engines being used from discarded planes that were being sold to Elon Musk to provide quick and energy for AI and where there's a problem with electricity or other available— what might be available power sources. [101:13] Speaker 1: There's a great deal of study needed And thank you for this moratorium. [101:18] Speaker 2: Speaker's time has concluded. Thank you for sharing your comments. The next speaker, please. Hi, I'm Honest Charlie Bodkin. I'm the co-founder of San Franciscans for Social Housing. Here to support this legislation, but I would encourage you to amend it today to make this moratorium permanent. Passing a temporary moratorium means that we'll be back next year to deal with this again. That will sap your time, and it will sap the community's time and energy. We should be spending our limited time figuring out how to fund and build the housing our city desperately needs. We need affordable homes for our communities, not data centers. Amend this legislation today and make this ban permanent. Thank you. [102:07] Speaker 1: Thank you for your comments. [102:08] Speaker 2: Agenda item numbers 4 and 5 are called together. [102:10] Speaker 1: Do we have anyone else who has public comment for these items? Madam Chair, public comment is now closed. Uh, Supervisor Walton. [102:23] Speaker 6: Thank you so much, Chair Melgar. I just want to, one, thank all of the speakers and the public who did come out. Uh, I did want to note that even some of the contents in the proposal kind of steer data centers towards existing in Bayview and South of Market and other parts of low-income and low-income geographical communities that are already burdened. Data centers are job killers, and they provide no benefit to our surrounding communities. And I do want to take note to some comments that were made, and I do believe that as we Move forward, the community will be able to have a voice in how we assess and what we look at. Obviously, we had limited time with the temporary data center moratorium, but I do just want to say that it has been stated that we do have limited experience in understanding data centers here in San Francisco, particularly data centers of a certain size. The report clearly indicates the concerns and issues that data centers do cause for us as a city. I won't repeat. So I do want to again thank Planning. I want to thank my colleagues. I want to thank everyone who came out and spoke. And I want to thank Lindsay Lopez Weaver from my office for all of her work and support on this extension. And just appreciate the committee taking the time for this and looking forward to moving this forward, um, with recommendation 4 to approve the report as a committee report and 5 to move this legislation forward for the moratorium extension with positive recommendation as a committee report. And thank you so much. [104:12] Speaker 1: Okay, thank you so much, Supervisor Walton. And I will make the motion as just stated by Supervisor Walton. Mr. Clerk. [104:24] Speaker 2: And this is a motion that both agenda item numbers 4 and 5 be recommended to the Board of Supervisors as committee reports. They're offered by the chair. On those motions, Vice Chair Chen? [104:34] Speaker 5: Aye. [104:35] Speaker 1: Chen, aye. Member Dorsey? [104:36] Speaker 5: Aye. [104:37] Speaker 1: Dorsey, aye. Chair Melgar? [104:38] Speaker 9: Aye. [104:39] Speaker 2: Melgar, aye. [104:40] Speaker 1: Madam Chair, there are 3 ayes on those 2 motions. That motion passes. Thank you. Thank you, Supervisor Walton, and thank you to everyone in the community who came in to weigh in. Thank you, uh, to planning staff. Uh, let's now go to item number 6, please. Uh, Mr. [104:53] Speaker 4: Clerk. [104:54] Speaker 2: Agenda item number 6 is an ordinance amending the planning code to streamline and clarify the landmark and historic district designation process, affirming the planning department's secret determination in making findings of consistency with the general plan and the 8 priority policies of Planning Code Section 101.1 in making findings of public necessity, convenience, and welfare. pursuant to board— pursuant to Planning Code Section 302. [105:17] Speaker 1: Thank you, Mr. Clerk. We now welcome the President of the Board, District 8 Supervisor Rafael Mandelman. [105:24] Speaker 2: Thank you, Chair Melgar and colleagues, for putting this on your agenda today. Although I am going to ask that you continue this item to the call of the chair. I want to just go a little bit back over some of the history of this legislation which has been kicking around for a good long time. I've been broadly supportive of the mayor's housing agenda. I think I have supported every upzoning process improvement, elimination of fees, and all of the other efforts that have been made over the last couple of years to encourage housing production in San Francisco. And I think You know, my support for that is based on a number of things, but included is the idea that we were way too reliant on discretionary processes to achieve our policy goals around the built environment. And it was wrong and also just inimical to our housing goals to have every developer who comes forward be entering into this You know, fun house or not so fun house where the rules were going to change and they were never going to know exactly what they were going to come out with. So to the extent that we in the state have gotten ourselves into a place where there's more certainty on the front end and people kind of know what they're walking into, I think that's very positive. When we were considering family zoning, which I supported, I expressed the concern though that in the aggregate. [107:01] Speaker 3: here, we could be— [107:02] Speaker 2: if we did not get ahead of the game with historic preservation, we could see the ministerial demolition of important historic resources without any real process to try to save them. That's the point. You don't want to be trying to save your historic resources now after the development applications come forward. In a lot of cases, that's now impossible. [107:23] Speaker 4: Thank you. [107:25] Speaker 2: And so the conversation that I had with the mayor at the time and with the planning department at the time was, doesn't it make sense to put the resources into our historic resource survey that we've been kicking around for years and years and years and never actually finishing and get that done on a more finite timeline? And as we do that work of identifying the best of the Category As, that is the most important of our landmarks, landmarks, or potential landmarks, to go ahead and landmark those buildings and let everyone know, this is a building that if you want to do something to it, you may well be able to do it. You may be able to build that 30-story building, but you're going to need to protect the character-defining features of that historic landmark. I found great receptivity to this idea in the planning department and in the mayor's office. I was grateful for that. They have been true to their commitments. The mayor put the money into the budget to do the survey work. You may have seen on our agendas I and a number of our colleagues taking advantage of the work that is being done to identify landmarks and even sometimes districts to designate those appropriately so everyone knows they're there going forward. In the course of that conversation, I asked the planning department whether there was anything that we could do legislatively Legislatively to make it easier since this was going to be a big project over the next few years, and what would it you know what could we do? They came to me with a in my view quite modest streamlining of our historic preservation process, of our landmarking process. That you know the biggest piece of this would be to take one of the two. 2 or 3 visits to the Board of Supervisors out of the equation. And so instead of having to start at the board and then go to— start at the board through a couple of months of the Board of Supervisors and then go to the Historic Preservation Commission for a couple more months and then come back to the Board of Supervisors for a few more months, we would take off potentially, you know, the requirement to come to the board in the first place. That could be useful, I think, would eliminate, would take some of the time out of this and would be, you know, a time-saved benefit for the planning department. But it is incredibly modest legislation. Its impacts are going to be minimal. It is directional. It is in the direction of making it slightly easier to preserve historic, the most important and significant of our historic buildings, but it is not a game changer in any way for that. I understand that there are concerns about any directionality towards more preservation in the city. I think it's wrong. I think it is a mistake. But I don't— I recognize that we are not there yet on this legislation. We probably won't get there while I am on this board. But I would ask that the committee continue the item to the call of the chair after public comment. [110:35] Speaker 1: Thank you, President Mandelman. So I want to recognize that we've been joined by District 5 Supervisor Bilal Mahmoud, and I will go to you next. [110:48] Speaker 2: Thank you, Chair Melgar, for the opportunity to speak here today, and thank you, President Mandelman and his aide, Renee Bejoy, Rich Sacre, Maggie Smith, Lisa Gluckstein, and the rest of the team from Planning for their work on this legislation. I've appreciated the opportunity to have this conversation about the role historic preservation plays in our landmark designation process and agree with President Mandelman that perhaps this conversation needs a bit more time to make sure we find the best way to incorporate an acknowledgment of landmarking's impact on housing and a way to offset the impact into our landmark designation workflow. Thank you. The fundamental underlying question in this legislation is not the merits of historic preservation on its own. Our city has immense historical resources that need to be considered in order to keep the charm of the city that we know and love. But it is the question of how do we weigh the value of a landmark designation with the impact that it may have on the ability for that site to contribute to our city's response to our housing crisis. Because make no mistake, landmark designations, while having merit on their own right, are a government constraint. They can reduce financial feasibility because they can require anything from ensuring the correct types of windows are used in an adaptive reuse project or require that buildings that would otherwise be demolished or greatly altered to be preserved. There's also an added layer of approval uncertainty that comes with building a landmark site. Projects demolishing landmark buildings do not qualify for SB 423 streamlining provisions, and projects that modify landmarks need to go before the Historic Preservation Commission to get a certificate of appropriateness regarding any changes to character-defining features. That's the status quo, and it's a status quo that has been called out by our own housing element. In Action 4.5.12, it lays out the direction the city would recommend it go in, saying, quote, consider the effects on housing in balance with the planning department's racial and social equity goals for any recommendation of approval, disapproval, or modification of landmark designations or historic district designations or approval of substantive new review processes or requirements for historic resources. Along the way in this process, staff suggested that historic preservation and housing production are not in conflict. And this is belied by the fact that the current wave of landmark designations that we are seeing is in response to the family zoning plan, as was mentioned earlier. So when this ordinance was initiated, it was framed publicly as enabling 2,000 more landmarks over the next 5 years, doubling the current number of landmarks without a way to balance that with our housing supply. So I had intended today to introduce amendments to this landmark streamlining legislation. that would require planning to do a housing capacity analysis as part of any Article 10 or Article 11 designation. These analyses would have to be considered by the board as part of their final landmark designation approval. The amendments also called for planning to reflect the lost housing capacity as part of a future housing element analysis. These are policies that other cities like New York already do. And so there's no reason San Francisco can't do it as well. I won't obviously be moving forward with those amendments today to respect the author's request to continue this item the call of the chair. But I will be looking forward to continuing this discussion hopefully in the new year and potentially seeing if there's other legislation absent this to modify Article 10, Article 11 to require a plan to consider these types of analyses and offsets for housing capacity and look forward to the continued engagement. [114:26] Speaker 1: Thank you, Supervisor Mahmood, and thank you, President Mandelman. So we— I can make the motion to continue this to the call of the chair, but because it's agendized, we do have to take public comment. So with that, and seeing no one else on the roster with comments, let's go to public comment. Mr. Clerk. Thank you, Madam Chair. [114:47] Speaker 2: Land Use and Transportation will now hear public comment related to agenda item number 6. Members of the public who wish to speak on this item can line up to speak along that right-hand side of this room. You will hear a chime at 30 seconds. That means you have 30 seconds remaining, and then you will hear a louder chime when your time is expired. Please respect the board rule that currently restricts you from providing comments directly to any member of this committee and address the full committee as a whole. I see we have speakers ready to provide public comment on this item. I'll start your time. [115:15] Speaker 1: Is it 2 minutes or 3 minutes? [115:17] Speaker 2: 2 minutes. [115:18] Speaker 1: Good afternoon, Chair Melgar and members of the committee, Supervisor Mandelman. I'm Catherine Petrin, speaking on behalf of San Francisco Heritage. Heritage strongly supports Supervisor Mandelman's amendments to the planning code to clarify the landmark designation process. In the same way that Mayor Lurie champions streamlining overall, this makes sense. The amendments, which are really relatively rather minor— we're not talking about radical change here— they really do support the mayor's goals. Seeking balance between protecting historic buildings and sites and the impacts of the upzoning plan. But I do want to say that preservation is not just about old buildings. We hear that preservation strongly aligns with our city's priorities around rent-controlled housing and tenant and small business protections. I'm not sure where we are with the amendments. That Supervisor Mahmoud is putting forward. But I do want to say that in general, when we hear this conflict between housing production and preservation, I want to just expand the conversation a little bit. It's not about how much housing is lost by designation. We see it the opposite way. We really do gain when we creatively incentivize housing production in existing buildings, sites, and districts. We retain character. We minimize demo and landfill— construction waste being the largest contributor to landfill. We get more units of housing. And I do think there are ways that we can emulate what New York City does. In New York City, there are approximately 38,000 designated sites, or 4% of that city's tax parcels. [117:11] Speaker 10: Thank you. [117:11] Speaker 1: And in San Francisco, the number is less than 0.5%. Thank you very much. [117:17] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. Let's have the next speaker, please. [117:19] Speaker 7: Good afternoon. [117:28] Speaker 2: My name is Peter Dworkin. I've been a San Francisco resident for 40 years, and I live in District 2. I'm not here representing any organization, just myself as a interested citizen. My first comment is that, and I think we do all agree, that San Francisco needs more housing. I think we can also agree that the truly valuable landmarks in San Francisco in our building environment should be protected. I think the difficulty, of course, is going to be how to achieve that balance. I'm not familiar with the proposed ordinance in detail, but I hope that the process by which buildings would be identified and before they could be landmarked and the argument for landmarking will be transparent and compelling, because otherwise I think the danger is, is that we err on the side of inhibiting housing production. For example, I don't understand why apparently the ordinance and even the mayor's policy is defining an addition of 2,500 units to the landmarked, you know, population. That seems backwards. Why start with a number when you don't know how many units are worthy of landmark status. I think the process should be built from the ground up based on, you know, an objective analysis of the quality of the real estate for landmarking. I would hope that there'd be a clear distinction between preserving buildings and preserving the artwork that may be in some of these buildings. I think we can all agree that valuable artwork should be preserved, But they can be preserved in different ways, including relocated to a new location that wouldn't require the preservation of the building. Thank you for sharing your comments with the committee. We have reached the 2-minute limit. We have to move on to the next speaker. Let's have the next speaker, please. [119:40] Speaker 1: Good afternoon. My name is Leslie Dickey, and I'm speaking as a resident of D2 and the United Neighborhoods United San Francisco, or NUSF. [119:50] Speaker 2: Which is a coalition of more than 60 neighborhoods and groups that advocate for tenants and small businesses and thoughtful, affordable housing. [119:58] Speaker 1: We support Supervisor Mandelman's amendments to the planning code to simplify the designation process for historic buildings and districts, the very things that draw visitors to our city and make those of us living here enjoy living in such a beautiful place. Tourism is a critical source of income for our city, and bringing in nearly $10 billion this year. [120:19] Speaker 2: One of the top reasons that people come to visit San Francisco is to see the sites and experience our various neighborhoods. [120:25] Speaker 1: Putting historic buildings and districts at risk could diminish valuable tourism income, our residents' experience, and local beauty. [120:34] Speaker 2: Thank you for your time. [120:35] Speaker 1: Thank you for your comments. Do we have anyone else who has public comment for agenda item number 6? [120:42] Speaker 2: Madam Chair. [120:43] Speaker 1: Okay, public comment on this item is now closed. Um, so as per President Mandelman's request, I make a motion that we continue this item to the call of the chair. On the motion offered by the chair that this ordinance be continued to the call of the chair, Vice Chair Chen. Aye. [120:58] Speaker 2: Chen, aye. Member Dorsey. [121:00] Speaker 4: Aye. [121:00] Speaker 1: Dorsey, aye. [121:00] Speaker 2: Chair Melgar. [121:01] Speaker 5: Aye. [121:02] Speaker 2: Melgar, aye. Madam Chair, there are 3 ayes. [121:03] Speaker 1: Okay, that motion passes. [121:05] Speaker 2: Thank you. [121:06] Speaker 1: Um, Mr. Clerk, let's go to item number 7. [121:09] Speaker 2: Agenda item number 7 is a hearing on the state of traffic enforcement and street safety in San Francisco. [121:14] Speaker 1: Okay, this hearing was requested by President Mandelman. Uh, the floor is yours. [121:21] Speaker 2: Thank you, uh, Madam Chair. Um, I am, uh, keenly aware, and it's appropriate, uh, that we are having this hearing today and then the hearing that I believe you're having at the Transportation Authority tomorrow, following what's always one of the most memorable and tragic events of our calendar yesterday, the memorial for folks who had died as victims of crashes. And so I've been having this hearing started 4 or 5 years ago. It's been kicking around for a long, long time. It's not actually the first hearing that I've had on traffic enforcement. The first hearing that I did on traffic enforcement was actually back when Sandy Fuhr was on the board, and she had called it because she was— she had noticed, I think in 2018 or 2019, the real drop-off in citations at that point and was concerned about the erosion, the loss of members from, from traffic companies. which is the, you know, the body in the police department that is formally kind of most tasked with, with traffic enforcement. So she was worried about that back in 2018, 2019. I was worried about that. And then things got— and we had our hearing, and then things got a whole lot worse. And so, um, uh, by 2021, uh, when this, uh, hearing got started, um, we were, uh, we'd fallen, um, you know, uh, to just a fraction of the citations that were being issued 10 years earlier, or less than 10 years earlier in 2014. Something like 4,000 citations in that year, down from, you know, much, much, much higher numbers back in 2014. Since that 2021 kind of nadir, we have seen seen gradually and through many of, you know, iterations of this hearing, um, we've gotten the positive news, um, that enforcement has picked up, and we have seen, um, more, uh, more folks being pulled over and reminded that they're, they're driving dangerously and sometimes given a citation for doing that. But we're still only at half the numbers that we were at pre-pandemic, which was already a massive slide from 2014. And, um, and we are seeing— and we'll— I know we'll talk some about this— like, not any significant increase. In fact, I think a decrease in folks being pulled over for speeding. That there are reasons why that may be. We can talk about that. Um, not the enforcement of the focus on the 5 violations that are the most dangerous that seem like would be, would be good. And so I do think, um, I mean, I'm going to ask, uh, that we file this hearing because I think it's, it's been, it's been alive for a long time. But I do hope that in the new year, um, you know, one or more supervisors will take on, uh, calling for a new hearing on traffic enforcement and continuing to check in, because I do think it is important. Um, one of the things that I've learned from the conversations with with PD is it is— there's a lot of stuff pushing the police department away from doing traffic enforcement. There is more work today associated with each citation than there was back in 2014. You cannot do traffic enforcement as efficiently as you could because of a variety of rule changes. There are risks inherent in traffic enforcement. You never really know what you're going to get when you pull somebody over. possibility of conflict or a bad outcome is higher. There's all sorts of reasons why if the public and politicians do not make clear that we want to see traffic enforcement, we're not going to see traffic enforcement. And so I do think that there's value in continuing to bang the drum, and I hope that supervisors will do that going forward. So today we're going to hear from Commander Brian Hu from the Special Operations Bureau. to talk to us about where the department is in their most recent data collection. We're also going to hear from Thalia Lang from SFMTA, who's going to talk to us about the speed cameras, which happily, you know, we've been able to put up, you know, 30-some, I think 33 speed cameras around the city. And I I think they are important and are important to improving safety where they're located. There are, of course, big differences between the tickets that people get from the speed cameras and the tickets that people get from an officer. Speed cameras are, of course, only at those 33 locations. Drivers learn where they are and change their behavior. And it's better, I suppose, to have 33 locations in the city where drivers know that they better not speed, but it would be nice if drivers had the fear that speeding anywhere or any, you know, dangerous driving anywhere might get them into trouble. And I think right now, there's still kind of a correct expectation that actually there's just— your odds of something bad happening to you if you're driving too fast or cutting people off in the crosswalk are— it's just not that much is going to happen. It's highly unlikely. So, So I guess with that, we will start on the PD side with Brian Hu. [127:06] Speaker 3: Thank you. Uh, good afternoon, President Mendelman and Chair Melgar and supervisors. Um, my name is Commander Brian Hu. I oversee the Traffic Company Special Operations Bureau. I'd like to introduce you to the team that we'll be presenting today. So, uh, Carl Nacita from, uh, Government Affairs, they'll be going through the slide deck for me. He works Chief of Staff for our department. My boss, who I directly report to, Deputy Chief Kim. Captain O'Connor, who's the captain of Traffic Company, who oversees all traffic-related issues. Lieutenant Brendan O'Connor, who's the lieutenant in charge of the Traffic Collision Investigative Unit. He oversees the traffic fatalities, and he also directly reports to Captain O'Connor. [127:47] Speaker 1: Excellent. [127:51] Speaker 4: Oh, perfect. [127:54] Speaker 3: So here, just a quick overcap of the Mayor's Street Safety Initiative. The mayor's put a lot of emphasis into this, so here are the things that we are focusing on: safer people, safer streets, safer vehicles, safer speeds, and post-crash care. And how are we going to do this? We have what we call a Street Safety Initiative Working Group composed of the following entities. We do meet once a week, about an hour and a half, whether it's in person or it's via Teams. So we get a lot of things done. Here's our partners. It's the mayor's office, obviously us, SFPD, DPH, SFMTA, and obviously other planning activities and planning entities within, within the city. Here you're very familiar with the High Injury Network. The High Injury Network, when you look at the clusters, historically is in the downtown areas, but we do have high injury networks that are throughout the rest of the city. Here's our enforcement operations by type. So if you look on the far left, those color rows are directed enforcement. Those come from district station captains, community meetings, supervisors, anything within the command staff that's derivative from community meetings. We also have what we call waves. Those are waves, meaning that we go back And we reoccur locations based on high injury networks, based on complaints. We do a touchpoint. Next, what we have is integrated enforcement. Integrated enforcement, that's with our red light cameras, our speed cameras, our partnerships, you know, with other agencies. And of course, what we have is education. So we truly believe that traffic enforcement is just not giving people a ticket, but it's also educating them, and hopefully it changes behavior. When you look at the yellow row that's in yellow, it talks about our stats and our total. So when we do our, you know, our grand total to the right, it's, uh, when we talk about the numbers, it's— you can look at for yourselves. In the middle, it's for this year, and then the other column, blue, is from last year's column. So when we talk about red light cameras, one thing I want to notice is the red light cameras, and I'll talk about in the next slide. But this particular slide, we've issued 10,000 citations for 2025, and for this year up into September, about 7,000 citations. So we have 19 red light cameras at 13 locations. This is from January 1st to September 2026. 7,000 citations. If you look at the column on the far left, the top 5 are the top 5 producing locations. Below that, the next one is the lowest 5 performing locations. I do want to make a note that 2 of the cameras the locations are zero, and that's due to the fact that one location has persistent construction, and that construction is long-term, so we don't know when that camera will be back working. The other location, there are some things that, that are obscuring the camera's point of view based on construction that was done. So we are looking into that and looking at the feasibility of, of how we can have that camera working, or thinking about like relocating that to another location. As we do know, having the red light camera locations, it is, you know, it is a very legislative process. And then we're just making sure that we are tracking that 2 of the camera locations aren't producing. [131:10] Speaker 2: And that's 6th and Folsom and Market and Octavia? [131:13] Speaker 3: Correct. [131:16] Speaker 4: That's— [131:16] Speaker 3: I got to put on my glasses, sorry. [131:20] Speaker 2: Yeah, I was— [131:21] Speaker 3: that is correct. Camera number 6. [131:22] Speaker 2: It seemed like those were locations where there was no violations of the red lights going on. [131:26] Speaker 3: All right, so here's the citations that you alluded to. When you look on the far left of the bar graph, 2016, that's obviously a high number, over 100,000. When you look at the far right, the far right is year to date from September. So when we talk about traffic citations, what we have, you know, we have paper citations and we also have, you know, like our electronic citations. The reason why our data is 2 months behind is because it's paper citations at the district stations that our analyst has to gather, compile, and update. We recognize that 2 months, we're trying to cut that in half by at least 1 month. We're hoping that next year we can go on a better footing. It's our goal and our intention is to have 2026 results a lot faster than waiting for 2 months. So when we talk about current staffing and shortages, 2016, we do know that the department you know, was a lot way more robust than we are right now. We currently have approximately 800 officers on patrol, and I have 20 officers in the traffic company. Obviously, in 2016, staffing was a lot more higher. This year to date, you know, we are on pace to exceed the number of traffic violations and also the Focus on the Five. So when we talk about the Focus on the Five, and I'll have the next slide about it, but all the district stations, you know, when it comes to traffic citations, you know, they're all amplified by, you know, calls for service, other community problems, community needs. So some stations are very robust and proactive about it and others not. It's not because they're not focused on that, because they have other competing interests, other competing priorities, which is calls for service. So this is our DUI enforcement operations. So part of our grant of OTS, Office to traffic safety is we do DUI enforcement. Those DUI enforcement, you know, by policy, by law, we have to announce that, which we do on social media with our locations. Here are our results. To date, we've done 5 checkpoints. Checkpoints are your normal standard where the vehicle enters a checkpoint and there's rules and regulations on how we handle that. Saturation, we've done 4. With the saturation, that's where the officers go out and do DUI saturation enforcement. We do have partnership with the California Highway Patrol and the San Francisco Sheriff's Department and San Francisco BART— or sorry, BART PD. To date, you know, when we look at it, one thing I want to note, we've done 10 DUI enforcements related to alcohol, and we issued 262 citations. So here's the slide that, you know, people, uh, want to drill down on. On the far left, this is the traffic company, uh, on the far left, and we have the 10 district stations. So the red is depicted for Focus on the Five, and then the blue is just normal citations. When we talk about Focus on the Five, you know, when we talk about the district stations, I do want to have to amplify that, you know, based on the president's question earlier, was that There's California state law that requires that we cannot do quotas. So I just want to make it clear that the department does not establish citation quotas. California law expressly prohibits state and local agencies from requiring peace officers to meet citation quotes. See California Vehicle Code 41600 through 41603, which define citation quotas and prohibit agencies from establishing policies requiring officers to meet them. So when we do traffic enforcement, we focus on the violations. We don't focus on the mode of transportation. So for example, if, if we're focusing on traffic enforcement, regardless of the mode of transportation, you know, it will be up to the officer's discretion to cite or to advise. So this bar chart, when you look at it on the far right, you know, it's for 2026. The middle is 2025, then 2024, then 2023 in blue. So regarding that, this— our citation numbers are to September, we, you know, and it is November, so we are anticipating that our citation numbers will increase more. I have the actual percentage that we're— what we think, and I'll talk about it in a later slide. But we are, as you can clearly see, we are up on the— up on the rise considered previous years. Here's focus on the 5 violations. This is obviously on the— when we talk about 2025 and 2026, it just shows that our numbers, you know, we are anticipating that our numbers will increase higher. Here are the injury collisions. So when you look at the bar graph, the red is the traffic fatalities, and then obviously the injury collisions are depicted in blue. So when you compare it from 2016 to now, the numbers actually aren't, you know, has decreased in 2016 and also the numbers have decreased from 2025 and 2024. So this is the breakdown by traffic fatalities by year and mode. So from 2016 to this November, I'll just focus on the far right column, which is 2026. So we have 13 pedestrians, we have 4 driver motorcycle, and then we have 2 bicyclists. So the blue is pedestrians, the dark tan is driver motorcycle scooter passenger, and the orange is the bicyclist. So here's the breakdown to the 2 pie charts. The pie chart on the left is 2025, and the pie chart on the right is 2026. We talk about the age of the victims and the percentage. So when we talk about pedestrians, we're at 13, which is 68% compared to last year. Last year was 16 and 64%. So here are the bar charts again for last year and for this year. One thing I want to note that last year, 56% of the pedestrians of the traffic fatalities were over, you know, up 65 and over. If you look at the highest trend now, the trend is 26%, and that age group is 50 to 59. Next is 21%, which is 40 to 49. So it's inverse. So previously we've had high uptick numbers with elderly people. Now, this— today's bar chart reflects that as the younger demographics. So this slide talks about the traffic fatalities, the age of driver and stand-up power devices, e-scooters, e-bikes, et cetera. And if you look out on the far left is 2026, and then the far right— sorry, the far left is 2025, and then the far right is 2026. This pie chart significantly talks about vehicle versus pedestrians at the crosswalk and mid-block. Last year's pie chart talks about 19. This year's pie chart talks 14 in the crosswalk. If you look at the demographics, when I say demographics, it's 7 were outside of the crosswalk, 5 were in the crosswalk, and then 2, 14%, is like we're still working on that. The big thing we want to amplify is that we see an uptick of people walking outside the crosswalk, you know, with regards to traffic fatalities. Here's from a pie chart from the DA's office when we talk about vehicle and pedestrians being charged. Left is 2025, this year 2026. You know, when we talk about it, the big significant one is adult cited misdemeanors. It's 5, or approximately 36%. So when we talk about our directed enforcement summary, when we talk about our totals and our advisements, so the grand total, you know, for combining last year and this year, we're at 7,306. When we talk about total violators contacted, total violations issued, but the bottom line that I want to see on the bottom row is like you have a 29% chance of giving a warning versus getting a citation. So basically 3 out of 10. Once again, it's up to the officer's discretion whether or not to cite or give an advisement. This year, if you look in the middle column, obviously we are way ahead of last year's results. So if you look in the bottom of the bar graph, it tells each mode of of how it happens. So for example, the first one is bicyclist versus truck. The next one is pedestrian versus muni, e-scooter versus delivery truck, solo moped, solo vehicle, tow truck versus pedestrian. vehicle versus e-scooter, vehicle versus motorcycle, and vehicle versus pedestrian. That's all I have for my presentation. I'll be more than happy to take any questions. I have my team here with me to help assist me. I do have— [141:20] Speaker 2: I got a couple questions. I know we have some folks in the audience, so I will try to be brief. But can we talk— can we go back to the slide that shows all the different entities that are doing— slide 9 that shows everybody who does traffic enforcement? So first, where are we with Traffic Company? [141:45] Speaker 3: Traffic Company is on the far left. [141:47] Speaker 2: I understand, but like in terms of like— having a staff— the hearing in 2018 or 2019 was Supervisor Feuer and me expressing a lot of anxiety because I think traffic company had dropped down into the 40s. Very bad. It's a big problem that it was down, you know, down to 40s, which really meant there were only like 30-something or maybe 20-something folks available on any given day. And I think now it's like 20, right? [142:14] Speaker 3: That is correct. So last year's meeting, Commander Luke Martin said the full staffing is approximately 80+ motorcycle officers. So we are currently staffed at 20, and we also have a program called SRT, the Solo Response Team. So we currently have 13 part-time solos at the district stations, and we have 4 in training right now. So we do have 20 full-time, 13 part-time, and 4 more being assessed to be part-time. [142:41] Speaker 2: And what does— I mean, what is Like, it looks like the type of traffic enforcement that's happening is pretty different across the stations. It looks like some of the stations, like Richmond Station, happily— I'm going to interpret here— Richmond has the ability to send their— or there's some folks out there who are super interested in doing traffic enforcement, but they also have, like, the ability to send officers out to do that. Maybe there are not a whole lot of other things going on that are taking them away from that. And they're also doing like a very significant proportion of focus on the 5 and 4. I mean, chef's kiss. We love what's going on in Rich— in the Richmond District. Except, um, if you look at where like fatalities are happening in the communities that are most impacted by, um, dangerous driving, I mean, certainly there's some of that in the Richmond, but I bet you could pick some other, some other stations that have more of that stuff. The problem is They also have like a whole lot of other things that are calling their officers to deal with assaults and shootings and whatever else is going on. So traffic— so if you happen to be in a part of the city that doesn't have, you know, the ability of Richmond Station to do that really great traffic enforcement, like you're only— the only people who could do that for you would be the members of traffic company, right? [144:03] Speaker 3: That is correct. So there's only 800 officers on patrol. So if you just do the math divided by 10, that's 80. We do know that the downtown stations have over 100. We do know that the west side stations don't even have that. When I was the captain of Terryville Station, as Supervisor Melgar knows and Supervisor Chen knows, like, I didn't have the capacity and the capability to do calls for service and to do traffic enforcement. So we do appreciate the modernization of the red light cameras and speed cameras, that does help. Every district station captain, you know, has a running chart of the most prolific locations. It's when the officers can get to that, they're competing with calls for service. Some of the other stations, we do know downtown stations where I was at, you know, it's based on staffing and calls for service and priority. When it comes to traffic enforcement and the traffic company, you know, not only do our officers do traffic citations, and we also respond to traffic fatalities. And those traffic fatalities do take quite a lot of effort to— and I'll let the lieutenant of TCAO talk about the workup for that, but it does take a huge burden of paperwork and investigative skills when it comes to traffic collisions. And we do know that the traffic collisions, we're still working on closing that. So every case that a traffic collision investigator gets is added to the pile that he or she already has. [145:28] Speaker 2: So it seems to me like a— it's still a significant problem that we have this understaffed traffic company, and I appreciate that you're trying to, you know, borrow some part-time folks out of the, out of the stations, but does the department have any sort of ambition toward or plan or notion of when a more robust building up of traffic company might happen? [145:56] Speaker 3: Yes, we do know that, that when the numbers from graduating classes come out, the Deputy Chief of Operations can, can help release officers. Staffing is always ongoing. You know, our goal is to, you know, beef up patrol. Patrol is the backbone of the police department responding to calls for service. doing community problem-solving, traffic-related enforcement. So we're hoping that every class that gets out, every officer, when we do movement, that there is incentives— not incentives though, but motivation to go out and do traffic enforcement. Traffic Company is a shell of its former self. When I first came in the police department, myself and Deputy Chief Kim, solo company, Traffic Company was at 100. Now we're at 20, which is 20%. So when we look at traffic enforcement, we do understand that our traffic officers are doing the best they can with what they have, which is basically, you know, an aging infrastructure fleet, you know, helping out with, with the red light cameras and also with the speed cameras. That does help out. [146:57] Speaker 2: Um, I don't think I'm getting— I got an answer, but it may be that you're not— I think you're not able to give me an answer. But when might— I mean, 8 years after we started asking this question, when might we be able to start building up traffic company? Yeah, good afternoon, Supervisor. Just to kind of answer that question, I know as the deputy chief of my bureau, in conjunction with the other deputy chief, we do have a discussion. Because there's a balance regarding the needs of each station. And I understand, like Richmond, they do a fantastic job on traffic. There's variable reasonings for that. But as we get more academy classes through, because currently there's 2, there's going to be another one starting in this month, as we're projecting 5 classes, we're looking at increasing our specialized units, which includes traffic companies. So it's not probably exact formula. I can't tell you it's going to be done in, you know, 5 years, 2 years, 3 years. It's really about how many recruits graduate from each academy, pass FTOs. We have to look at obviously promotions and everything else because we're short-staffed all across all ranks. So it's really for us balancing it and kind of determining the numbers. So just to be very frank, I just can't tell you when exactly the numbers will be up, but I know it's a constant discussion among all the bureaus, all the deputy chiefs, and we realize that it is a priority for us to, for traffic enforcement to, you know, make sure the streets are safe, but it's a balancing act between the needs of the station and specialized units. And for us, looking at each station as we increase personnel on the streets, because we get a twofold, right? on their spare time, they can do traffic enforcement. Rather, when they look at our motorcycle officers, they're strictly for traffic enforcement accidents. So for us, it's— we're looking at the balance of that, and eventually we're hoping to, as the academy class comes out, adding more numbers to the traffic company. Hopefully that kind of— Yeah, I mean, that's a little more— it's, it's indefinite, which I understand. It you know, from your perspective, needs to be. I guess I would push and I would encourage if someone takes this hearing up next year, you know, I think it would be good to get a little bit more definite about actual goals for the building up of traffic company over like a period of time. And I do think— I mean, how many homicides have we had in San Francisco this year? I want to say 20. [149:40] Speaker 3: I don't know the exact number. [149:41] Speaker 2: I think it's a number. But in the 20s. But for homicides or traffic fatals? [149:45] Speaker 1: No, no, no. [149:46] Speaker 2: I mean homicides. [149:47] Speaker 3: Okay. [149:48] Speaker 2: Because my suspicion is that when police are thinking about like, what do we need to deal with? Like the most serious thing that we need to deal with is homicides. We got to have enough resource to make sure that we're dealing with the homicides. I think the homicide numbers are kind of in the neighborhood of the traffic fatality numbers. And both are hard to prevent. But I think they're, you know, I think for the public and for the politicians, like, I do think I worry about an underappreciation maybe in the department of, you know, the importance of this work of actually really— and again, because like in so many ways, I feel like the signals that have been sent out to the police over the last 10 years are like— [150:36] Speaker 10: Yes. [150:36] Speaker 2: Dial it down. Dial it down less. But around enforcement, or particularly around the kinds of offenses that are, you know, leading to fatalities, the focus on the highest stuff, I think, again, the point of these hearings is like, no, please do more. And, and I do think like asking you all to come back next year with a plan, the same plan Sandy Feuer wanted in 2018, of like, how is traffic company going to get rebuilt? And that's part of it because with our, what we call our SRT program, a Special Response Team for the motorcycle officers, is we're having them do part-time work. So because of that, because it takes about 2 months to train an officer just on the motorcycle itself, and then with experience of doing all this. So we have these SRT officers. As we get more bodies, we can just transfer them over and then they're just off and running. [151:29] Speaker 3: Right away. [151:30] Speaker 2: So we do have a plan trying to, like, succession plan to make sure we have officers to rebust once we get personnel. And also with the help of the red lights, the speed cameras, we're helping all that can, you know, reduce traffic fatalities or anything else. But I know for us it's really about staffing and again trying to be very thoughtful as much as possible. But know that it is a priority for us and that's why we try and set send out the message to the captains and everybody else about enforcement. And so when they do have time, our messaging is try to do enforcement, try to, you know, either give out tickets or educational-wise, but do that traffic enforcement at the station level. But, uh, obviously when we talk about Traffic Company, we do, you know, we could always do better. We do have a lot of work ahead of us, and I just want to send the message we don't take it lightly. We want to staff up. I mean, especially for myself, As the deputy chief of that bureau, I want to increase my staffing, you know, but it's really a balance with the other bureaus to make sure everybody has enough help because, again, everybody has needs, right? There's always a priority for the neighborhood, each individual station. And again, I just want to make sure you guys understand that we don't take it lightly and we do really want to beef up our traffic company. I think my last question, and I'll get out of the way. Why is the number— why is the percentage of focus on the 5 relatively so low for Traffic Company? Good afternoon, everybody. I'll reintroduce myself. Acting Captain David O'Connor from Traffic Company. I oversee the motorcycle unit that does traffic enforcement citywide. I also oversee Traffic Collision Investigations Unit, as well as a couple of other units that are within the division. It's hard to say exactly why those numbers are not— the percentage is not higher. Traffic company is directed citywide based upon specific complaints in certain locations. [153:49] Speaker 6: It could be as specific as this particular intersection or this particular stop sign. [153:57] Speaker 2: It could be any number of very specific complaints. We build a directed enforcement calendar based upon all of that information. The officers at Traffic Company every day are sent out to those locations based upon different criteria that lead to building of this traffic enforcement calendar. And so sometimes I can't say specifically, you know, what they might be asked to look at, but sometimes The enforcement that they take at those locations that they're sent to are just dictated by what they observe once they get there. You know, I think that it probably could be, you know, increased or encouraged to focus more highly on the focus on the five. But I think that the overall numbers are pretty good, and the traffic company responds to. hundreds of complaints every year about specific locations. And these are, you know, the numbers that result. What is a classic non-focus on the 5? I mean, what of this, like, 5,500? It could be any number of things. I think, like, recently, some issues that have come to play are, you know, e-device issues, you know, riding on the sidewalk. Some would be the transit lane enforcement, keeping transit lanes free and clear so that public transportation is able to operate efficiently throughout the city. [155:45] Speaker 6: So those would be just a couple of examples. [155:47] Speaker 2: And I think this is a question for the commander, but I I took the point about, um, you know, not wanting to do quotas, although I think we're like, we're clearly not doing quotas because we're far off of like— I don't think we're— I'm not worried. I don't know, maybe, you know, maybe I need to talk to the city attorney, but it doesn't seem like to me that we're in danger of being nailed for, um, a quota-based system. Do we keep track of the advisements though? [156:11] Speaker 3: Yes, we do. So, uh, on one slide I can go back to, but it talks about advisements. [156:16] Speaker 2: Sure, let's look at that. [156:17] Speaker 4: that. [156:17] Speaker 2: Which one is it? They're not really tracked, uh, citywide. [156:25] Speaker 6: Those would be for traffic in particular. [156:27] Speaker 2: Oh, total warnings, advisements. [156:38] Speaker 3: Yeah. And then once, uh, I, I do want to mention that this is by traffic company, this and that department as a whole. [156:45] Speaker 4: Right. [156:46] Speaker 2: I mean, it would be interesting, right? Because we're— [156:50] Speaker 7: I am— [156:52] Speaker 2: I want more tickets to be given, a lot more tickets to be given, but I'm not sad if there's a lot more no ticket, just pulling you over and letting you know that, you know, you're driving like a maniac and you need to stop. And if I saw in these numbers like evidence that there was a ton of that going on, then that would be reassuring, although I don't see that in these numbers, I see, you know, less advising and more tickets. So I don't— [157:15] Speaker 3: Well, if you look at the middle column, you have a 3 out of 10 of being advised, meaning you have a 70% chance of getting a citation. So I think those odds are, you know, when it comes to advisement, you know, officers are, you know, are human and they're, you know, like, they'll deal with the totality of the whole thing. You know, for example, let's say that an officer is writing a citation for a violation and then somebody comes by and does a worse violation, maybe that officer would say, hey, slow down, do whatever, and then get on the motorcycle to go chase after the worse egregious one. [157:50] Speaker 4: All right. [157:53] Speaker 2: I think Supervisor Dorsey has questions or comments. Thank you, President Mandelman. So I will say, I just in general to the staffing issue, This has sort of been my broken record issue, and honestly, the biggest disappointment of my first term was not being able to make more progress on just police staffing generally. Right now, the numbers that I see, the full-duty staffing shortfall department-wide is 720 officers. That means that close to a third of the police department we're supposed to have isn't there. [158:31] Speaker 6: So I hope we can make progress on that. [158:36] Speaker 2: I just feel like that is sort of the thing that bedevils so much of the work that we do want to do on so many public safety challenges that we face. I also wanted to say that I am grateful to Chief Liu and Chief— former Chief Scott and everybody at SFPD for their support for the speed enforcement camera program. When we went to Sacramento to lobby for this, and that was a multi-year effort, I think it took 6 tries, and it was always disappointing to see that there's a lot of law enforcement agencies that were standing in the way of that. SFPD never did, so I just appreciate that. But on the topic of the speed cameras, you alluded to this a little bit already, but can you speak more about how the introduction of speed cameras has changed how the department spends its resources? [159:32] Speaker 3: If you're asking about specific numbers, SFMTA would have to talk about that. We don't talk about the speed camera metrics. I can talk about red light camera metrics because the red light camera officers work for me. But when it comes to speeding, you know, directed enforcement, You know, even if there's a camera there, if we have a directed enforcement, you know, I'll let the captain talk more in depth about it. But we, we just don't avoid locations because there's a red light camera or a, like, a speeding camera, if that answers your question. [160:06] Speaker 4: Okay. [160:07] Speaker 2: Is there, is there data that you're getting from it that's helping to inform how you're doing traffic enforcement generally? I think at least anecdotally, I think citywide we're seeing more consciousness about speeding, about red lights, because some people just don't know where the devices are, and it seems to have changed behavior citywide. Like the commander said, it doesn't really affect, you know, our targeted enforcement. We're probably less likely to go do enforcement at locations, possibly. We're just not getting as many complaints at locations where there are speed cameras or where there's red light cameras. So in that regard, it probably could because we're just not getting as many complaints at locations. I don't have specific data to support that, but anecdotally, I think that's what we're seeing. [161:01] Speaker 4: Okay. [161:03] Speaker 2: And in the presentation, I think it's pages where it gets into some of the Data on injury collisions and fatalities. Just for my edification, is that the full DPH data or is that the SFPD's own data? Do we have pages on slide 12 through 18? [161:22] Speaker 3: That's both. [161:22] Speaker 4: Okay. [161:23] Speaker 3: So obviously with the data we know about traffic fatalities, that's why we went to November 9th. We do understand that there was another one that happened over the weekend, but when we submitted the slides, it was with the pulling of the data. So to answer your question, yes, we, we do both. [161:38] Speaker 5: Great. [161:40] Speaker 2: Okay, thanks. [161:40] Speaker 1: Supervisor Chen. Thank you, Chair Melgar. Hi, Commander Ho. I would just like to follow up on slide number 9 again. I just want to ask more questions. Our understanding is that it's only 29% of the traffic division citations focus on Vi. And my— I think you talked a little bit about it, and I understand why it's sort of staffed. But then again, I want to ask this question again. What is your plan to increase the percentage? You know, what are some of the possible plans that we can support to increase To increase staffing, maybe? [162:29] Speaker 3: Yes, just like the Deputy Chief mentioned, staffing, staffing, you know, meaning that our long-term goal is to bring the SRTs, our part-time motorcycles, to our unit full-time. However, you know, just losing those 13 plus 4, that's patrol, you're losing 17 officers. And if you're at a district station, You know, for example, like if you're at Taravo or Richmond, losing 1 or 2 officers, that's more of an impact versus losing an officer at Southern or Central where those stations have more officers. So that's part of our Band-Aid fix, meaning that to get more officers on the SRT, and then also having more officers, you know, try out, you know, for it, have a list so that when openings open up or when we have the ability to purchase more more motorcycles, we'll have, you know, an officer that we can assign. So it is a process. You know, our motorcycle unit, it's— our training mandated by post is very, very difficult and very, very challenging. So, you know, like, we do have to think about innovative ways of getting younger officers interested in riding the motorcycles so they can pass. We do have a 50% attrition rate of officers who can't ride. Just because they just don't have the experience. So going through our motorcycle unit, it's not because we don't want people to become— ride motorcycles. The reason why our program is so tough, we impose standards so that way officers can operate because San Francisco, we all know, is not flat. It's hilly, a lot of streets, a lot of turns. We have a lot of tracks. So we want to make sure that our riders are very well experienced. So program of the SRT, bringing it to full-time, purchasing more motorcycles, have officers that are willing to come down, and also having a program where officers can experience that this is something they want to do in 5 to 7 years. They have a goal of how to become a better rider. [164:25] Speaker 8: Thank you. [164:27] Speaker 1: And also on the 70% of the blue belt, do you guys have a breakdown into each of the categories? For example, I heard, you know, red lane enforcement, scooters enforcement on pedestrian walkway, right? Do we have a category— do we have data on, like, each of the category? Like, how many of the citation actually it's due to red lane enforcement, for example? [164:54] Speaker 3: So if you look at the bottom of the graph on this chart, it talks about red lights, stop sign, you know, pedestrians, suspended license, unlicensed license. What it doesn't talk about is the specific locations. So if that's what you're asking about. [165:18] Speaker 1: So where would red light enforcement fall into? [165:22] Speaker 3: So red light enforcement is 600— [165:25] Speaker 1: Not red line, red light. Like traffic, uh, traffic red light enforcement. [165:33] Speaker 3: Sorry. [165:33] Speaker 2: I think, uh, to your question, Supervisor, I think we just focused on the folks of the 5 for, for this, and we didn't break down all the different types of violations that were cited. We just clumped everything into other. [165:46] Speaker 1: Okay, so am I clear that, uh, the 70% including transit link, like the red light enforcement? [165:52] Speaker 2: Yes, all the violations. It could be like no turn on left people are doing, or no U-turn, stuff like that. It's all combined. [166:00] Speaker 1: All combined. Okay. Is there a way to separate the data into more of the category that may be the 70% we're able to identify, not a top 5? [166:10] Speaker 2: I think the citations that are given by eCitation can be parsed out. That would be probably, you know, kind of a— I think it would be by site, actually vehicle code violation. So I think that probably could be done. [166:35] Speaker 1: That I will— my office will follow up with that because this is also very important with like the whole infrastructure of like designing and how can we also make sure that our public transit is moving on time and efficient. And my other question is, I also noticed that the Ingleside District has one of the lowest rates of traffic citations, despite having a concentrated corridor along the high injury network. Does the department have protocols to ensure enhanced enforcement of traffic violations? stations along the high injury corridors? Because in District 11 alone, on Mission Street, we have 2 fatalities in the last 18 months. [167:19] Speaker 3: So yes, I'm very familiar with the 2 traffic fatalities, and I have a lieutenant here that can, that can speak about that. But when it comes to traffic enforcement, the high injury network, each district station captain is aware, each of their patrol lieutenants are aware. And then of course it comes through with competing interests. One thing I do want to amplify that Ingleside, it's one of the— it's a very, very large district like, uh, like Taraville. So you may have an officer that needs, requires assistance and asks on the radio, and there may be another officer that's on a traffic stop or like has to go drive. So Ingleside, I could— I used to work at Ingleside, so I do know the challenges of working in that district. It's very large and very few. So you can spend easily your shift just backing your coworkers instead of doing traffic enforcement because when we're talking about responding for calls for service. [168:15] Speaker 1: And then how can we support, for instance, Ingleside Station to help because it's definitely under the high injury network? I mean, I'm very concerned. My constituents are very concerned because within the last 18 months, it's more than 2 fatalities. That's also Geneva and San Jose. That's also another very tragic case. [168:39] Speaker 3: What we can do, and we do do this, so we have these meetings called All Hands on Deck. The commanders and deputy chiefs, we speak about, for example, Deputy Chief Kim and I, we separate, and I'll talk about the traffic enforcement. I'll ask the district station captains to focus on traffic enforcement. when possible. So yes, that message is being relayed out. One thing I'll have to say is competing interests are calls for service. [169:09] Speaker 1: Got it. Thank you. Thank you, Supervisor. So I had a couple questions. [169:17] Speaker 4: Captain— [169:17] Speaker 1: well, no, First Commander. I was confused because in your presentation, you started out the presentation talking about the High Injury Network and the Street Safety Initiative that the mayor has rolled out, then the captain talked about how the schedules are set based on complaints. So which is it? [169:38] Speaker 3: So it's a combination of everything. So let me go back to the slide if that will help. So we have directed enforcement, we have waves and integrated enforcement, and then obviously education. So on the high injury network, traffic company, you know, it's— how can I say it? They're pushed and pulled in a lot of directions. So when it comes to the high injury network, you know, and once in a while— not once in a while, but there's common vehicle violations associated with a high injury network. [170:11] Speaker 2: Yeah. [170:12] Speaker 3: So the directed enforcement, you know, officers are there. And when we go back to the slide, High injury network, pretty much downtown, you know, it's a high injury network. So every time our traffic company does directed enforcement, you know, they are, you know, working on focus on the 5, directed enforcement, and any type of vehicle violation that happens. [170:33] Speaker 1: Okay, so my question, I guess we're going to get into it tomorrow when we have the hearing about the Street Safety Initiative and what that's yielding. But, you know, I guess my question is, if the portion of the time that traffic companies spend, say, on the high-injury network, you know, I personally love it when I look on Nextdoor and my neighbors are going crazy because somebody's on Monterey enforcing and everybody's like, watch out. It's like, great, right? That's exactly how it should be. And people should be, like, more careful because they know there's going to be enforcement. That's the whole point. But I wonder what the feedback mechanism is to MTA or, you know, DPH that we have, say, focused on the first 5 on Ocean Avenue. And we did like 3 days or whatever. And we saw, you know, a relationship between that and less injuries. Like, how does that happen? What is the collaboration and feedback mechanism between, you know, you guys and the other agencies who then control how, you know, we painted those lanes or how we, you know, are setting the speed limits or, you know, the light and how people are, you know, like, I'm wondering what the mechanism is. [171:58] Speaker 3: So, So Captain O'Connor and I have meetings and sidebar meetings when we talk about street safety. So every time there's a traffic fatality, you know, our unit will go out there and look at the lighting, you know, look at the cameras, and look on a way of how to improve things, whether it's increasing the diameter of the traffic lights, for example. You know, all of those things when we talk about traffic engineering. When it comes to actual officers on the ground, You know, very challenging when you only have a unit of 20, which means that if you do the math, only 10 are working on each side. And then if you do it 2 shifts, there's only 5. [172:35] Speaker 4: Mm-hmm. [172:36] Speaker 3: So that means like right now, looking at my clock, there's only 5 traffic officers working for the whole city. You know, so when we talk about traffic enforcement, you know, amplify that, you know, with, on, you know, especially with the weather as it's happening. So we anticipate that there will be more traffic collisions. with the weather. On sunny days where we're able to do traffic enforcement, we do the best we can with what resources we have. So we do message to the district stations, traffic company can't do it by themselves, we need help. And then the help is the district station officers helping out when they can. [173:12] Speaker 1: Yeah, no, I understand that. And I understand that you are Staffing is the first thing that's been a challenge in this whole situation. I was wondering what the feedback mechanism is. Or, you know, I have this constituent that since we did the pedestrian improvements in front of West Portal, he's— you know who I'm talking about— he's like out there with a camera every weekend recording the people who keep going straight even though now it says do not enter, right? And, you know, he records and he posts them online so everybody can see, right? So, I mean, I'm wondering if your officers see 10 people doing, you know, the illegal right turn, you know, how does that make it back to the MTA and say, like, this illegal right turn on this high-injury corridor keeps happening all the time, maybe you should, like, change the sign, or, you know, like, how How does that happen between citation and between other people getting involved? [174:17] Speaker 3: That's a great question, and that's something we could socialize. Is there a trigger or something that breaks, like, hey, if this happens so many times? I don't know. I definitely can ask about that and get back to you on that. [174:30] Speaker 1: It just seems it would be empowering to the officers to do something about this instead of just, you know, Asking us to always be catching people. [174:38] Speaker 2: Yes, Supervisor, I would say it's also upon the captain themselves because a lot of times for our traffic company as a whole, we're support for all the stations regarding citations and everything else. Because even at full staffing, I could honestly say there's not enough cops to do traffic enforcement all over the city. That's why we rely on the officers at the station. So we're there to help. Even now, On certain days to increase the operations, our motorcycle cops might work with the station level and to help them regarding like shooting LIDAR, like speed. They'll have their officers do the traffic stop while someone's shooting LIDAR. We'll do stuff like that to increase the numbers. But to your question, I think it's upon the captains at each station to figure out, hey, if this is a constant issue, like maybe that corridor, to contact Department of Public Works— I'm sorry, but MTA— about adding a stop sign or doing this or so forth, things like that. [175:36] Speaker 7: I see. [175:37] Speaker 2: So it's not really upon traffic company to do that. But we do do accidents where they have access to our accident reports. So even MTA can review and see what are the issues in these corridors. So just to go back regarding the high— injury network. Like, they will do— the plan is to do enforcement in the high injury network areas. But it's like the captains might go, hey, we have a complaint, it's increased in this area, then we'll send more officers there to do some enforcement. So it's pretty much trying to pinpoint on the high injury network where to do enforcement that makes sense. So we collaborate using all that information enforcement. So hopefully that answers your questions regarding, like, again, for certain issues like, you know, like if they need another stop sign or something else, I would say it's upon the captain to kind of reach out to DPT— or I'm sorry, MTA— and talk about re-engineering and see what they can do. [176:37] Speaker 1: I see. Okay, so back to something you just said, and just prompts a question to me. So if it's the captains who are working on deploying folks to do citations in the high-injury corridors. It seems to me like the focus on those 5 would be even more important, you know, because we know that those are the high-injury corridors, and we know that that's the behaviors that tend to hurt people the most. So it puzzles me that it's just left up to them to— [177:17] Speaker 2: No, it's a combination. So I would say like the station captains, they have a better pulse of what's going on in their districts. So again, depending on the personnel, even we spend overtime to do enforcement because again, it's a priority for us to make sure even though we might have some staffing shortages, we need to make sure there's still operations. to make sure, you know, we do traffic enforcement. So it's a combination of the station captains, getting more input from them, assisting them with our motorcycle officers, you know, for enforcement. So it's a combination. It's not like a silo just for us to determine. It's also for the station captains. So it's, it's a combination of both of us working together. [177:57] Speaker 1: Okay, thank you so much. And thank you very much, President Mandelbaum. [178:02] Speaker 2: Uh, thank you, Chair Melgar. Thank you, Thank you, Chief and Commander and Captain, for your presentations. I think we should move to the MTA, and we'll bring up Thalia Lang. [178:14] Speaker 4: Thank you. [178:36] Speaker 2: It's very exciting. [178:44] Speaker 1: Ready? Awesome. Hello, good afternoon, Chair Melgar and members. Thanks so much today for having us for this update on the San Francisco's Speed Safety Camera Program. My name is Talia Lang. I'm the program manager for the speed camera program at MTA. All right, great. So as of this past September, the San Francisco Speed Safety Camera Program has been operating for 18 months. And at this milestone, we are happy to report that the program continues to change driver behavior for good. In this update, I'll go over a little bit of background on the program and focus mostly on program performance. Safe— the Safe Systems approach. Safe speeds is one of the core elements of the Safe System approach, and in addition to automated speed enforcement, the city also uses a variety of other strategies to encourage people to drive at safe speeds. Other speed management tools include reduced speed limits, traffic calming devices, signal timing changes, street redesign, and education and outreach around speed safety. So given the limited number of currently allowed cameras in San Francisco, it's vital that speed cameras work in tandem with other speed management tools to provide necessary safety benefits and ultimately as part of San Francisco's Safe System approach. Okay, next slide, please. So why speed cameras? Well, unsafe speeding is the leading cause of death and serious injury on San Francisco streets. In the event of a collision between a vehicle and a pedestrian or bicyclist, the vehicle speed will largely determine the survivability of the crash. Speed safety cameras are a proven tool to address excessive speeding and reduce severe and fatal traffic injury— traffic collisions. Next slide, please. And how did speed cameras come to San Francisco? Our camera program is authorized via Assembly Bill 645, which enables 6 California cities to establish automated enforcement for a 5-year pilot period. The bill outlines some overarching basics, including that a vehicle must be traveling at least 11 miles per hour over the speed limit to receive a citation. The number of cameras is limited based on the city's population, and San Francisco gets 33 camera locations. And just to note that San Francisco was the first to launch, followed by Oakland, and now we have some other cities starting up, such as LA and San Jose. Next slide, please. And this slide shows some more specific information in the bill, including the penalty range, that these violations are civil penalties, not moving violations, and that the penalties are issued to the owner of the vehicle, not the driver, and that there must be a warning period of 60 days with no fee associated. Lastly, there are some requirements about eligible locations, including high injury streets, streets in school zones, and streets with documented racing issues. Thank you. Next slide, please. And this slide just touches on how San Francisco located our 33 camera locations, utilizing the criteria outlined in the bill and applying it in ways that make sense for San Francisco. Next slide, please. Our locations are shown as the 33 dots you see here. Each of the street segments was chosen because of a combination of speed-related collisions, concentrations of vulnerable roadway users, and documented outlier speeding. Next slide, please. And moving right into program performance. As I mentioned previously, overall we are seeing the program meet its speed reduction goals. And at the 18-month mark, we have done some specific analysis on performance. So first and foremost, the authorizing bill for the program, again, AB 645, requires cities to evaluate camera locations using certain speed reduction thresholds by the 18-month mark of operations to assess any need for camera deactivation or relocation. And as of September 20th, 2026, MTA's speed safety camera program has been operational for 18 months, and we're happy to report that all 33 camera locations meet at least one of the 3 mandated speed reduction criteria. And those criteria are around 85th percentile speed reduction, severe speeding reduction, and repeat violator reduction. Next slide, please. So beyond the speed reduction criteria outlined in the bill, For the 18-month mark, we also have some other metrics we regularly use to analyze performance, including speed survey data or tube data collected each quarter and analysis of issued violations. From our speed survey data, we have been able to look at some important behavior trends. Prior to speed camera implementation, there were about 50,000 vehicles going 10 miles per hour or more over the speed limit per day at camera locations. And post-implementation, there are now about 7,000 vehicles going 10 miles per hour or more per day over the speed limit. This is a nearly 84% decrease across camera locations in the city and translates to around 42,000 fewer instances of speeding per day. Next slide. Speeding dropped at every camera location, including somewhere nearly 1 in 3 drivers had been going 10 or more miles over the speed limit. Next slide, please. So moving on to the analysis of issued violations. We've had approximately 226,000 warnings issued since the start of citation issuance back in August of 2025 and approximately 235,000 citations issued since August of 2025. An important note is that though fewer people are speeding overall, which we know through our speed survey data, the number of warnings and citations can fluctuate due to a variety of factors such as ongoing refinements to to technology and staffing issues. Next slide, please. And now moving on to repeat speeding data. Our analysis shows that the majority of recipients, 62.9%, do not receive a second warning or citation, suggesting that a single notice is sufficient to change behavior for most drivers. Overall, 80.6% of recipients receive no more than 2 notices. Next slide, please. And lastly, a look at egregious speeds. Since the program began issuing citations in August of 2025, egregious speeds have decreased and are remaining at lower levels. The percentage of citations issued to drivers going 16 miles or more over the posted speed limit has decreased from over 50% at program launch to less than 30% today. Next slide, please. All right. So I spoke a little bit earlier about the 18-month speed reduction criteria set forth by the bill, and I mentioned that all 33 of San Francisco's camera locations meet at least one of the speed reduction criteria. So technically, San Francisco is not required to remove or relocate any cameras at this point. However, in the coming months, the MTA will be reviewing each camera location to understand if certain locations could be more impactful elsewhere. Specifically, we'll examine things like updated collision information and other important factors such as geographically equitable dispersion. Moving a camera to a new location will likely take about 6 months, and before any relocation, the agency would need to make time for community review, SFMTA board approval, and all associated disassembly and installation work. Next slide, please. And starting to wrap up, I wanted to quickly talk about program funding and reinvestment. Program net revenue is being reinvested back into San Francisco streets. That means funding going to traffic calming efforts to support pedestrian safety citywide. Our first year's revenue after addressing program costs totals approximately $2.2 million. Funds will primarily go towards advancing a new data-driven, equity-focused approach to prioritize installation of speed humps and related traffic calming features on local residential streets, and some revenues will fund new rectangular rapid flashing beacons. A reminder, speed safety cameras are designed to deter speeding and save lives, not generate fines. Next slide, please. All right. Finishing up. Just as a note, our quarterly program data is available online at Data SF. We do publish that quarterly. We are getting started with that camera relocation review currently, and that will continue into early 2027. We are continuing to coordinate with other pilot cities to share lessons learned and ensure consistency. And we've just started a regional education campaign with sister cities of San Jose and Oakland. And lastly, we do want to look at policy changes to expand the number of camera locations, improve program efficiency, and extend program duration in the coming years with continued pilot success. Thanks so much. And with that, I will take any questions. Okay, Supervisor— President Mendelmann. [187:26] Speaker 2: Thank you, Chair Melgar. Um, thank you so much for this presentation. Thank you for your work. Uh, it's exciting to see this happening. Um, and, uh, you know, I, I suspect the feeling among my colleagues— I think, I think we've all signed on to Supervisor Dorsey's resolution asking for more, please. Um, and I guess I'm wondering if you can address from the agency's perspective, the possibility of more pleas? And what are the steps? Require state legislation? And have we started that conversation? How hard do we think— this was very hard to get approval even for the 33 we got. So any preliminary thoughts on how we get more? [188:09] Speaker 1: Yes, definitely. That's definitely conversations that we're having and thinking about. Strategy moving forward and being mindful of that strategy and working with our other cities that are starting off and continuing to collect data and provide more justification as we move along. We do— it's a 5-year pilot, so it's of course working towards 2030 for us. We're going to be looking at ways to push for new legislation We are strategically thinking about that right now and how to move forward. I will say we want to be very collaborative with the other cities that are also moving this forward. [188:53] Speaker 2: It'd be great to do it before 2030 if we can. Is there any way to look at whether these cameras are having any impact on driver behavior other than at the location where they— [189:10] Speaker 1: Sure. [189:10] Speaker 2: I mean, you can tell different stories. You can tell a story of— and I think the most likely story is that they impact driver behavior where they are and nowhere else. But that might not be the case. It might be that if people are driving more thoughtfully in one place, that it carries over and has larger impacts. It could also be that people get through that zone and then speed up, and there could be like a you know, a weird like Murphy's Law kind of thing where actually in other places they're driving worse because they've gotten out of the zone. Is there any work the MTA is doing to think about how these cameras affect overall driver behavior? [189:47] Speaker 1: Yeah, that's a great question. Thank you. So we did publish an 18-month report, and in that report we do reference a study by a transportation group out of UC Berkeley called SafeTrek. And they have done a preliminary analysis. [190:06] Speaker 4: It— [190:06] Speaker 1: the research paper isn't quite published yet, but hopefully it will be published soon. But where they did look at the citywide effects of the speed camera program using telematic data, sort of bigger data. So different sources of data, but showing some really great results and similar reductions. And one of the things I did see is that the benefits extended beyond camera locations. So speeding declined both at the camera sites and comparison sites because they used control studies. So at least for the first 6 months-ish of the program. They are continuing to look at that— at this in more detailed studies, and we will also also have more of a detailed evaluation towards the 5-year mark. [190:57] Speaker 2: Great, thank you. [190:58] Speaker 1: Supervisor Chen. Thank you, Chair Melgar. The speed camera pilot program definitely have proven it's a game changer, especially in my district, a location along the high injury corridor. There was an enormous 90% initial drop in severe speeding after installation of the speeding camera. That is amazing. And I— my question is, the warning period at the beginning of the speed camera program was also very effective at reducing speeding. [191:38] Speaker 8: Yes. [191:39] Speaker 1: Is SFMTA exploring similar education campaign for the red light camera program as we will see more cameras coming online? That's a great question. I'm not the program director for that, but Joel's nodding his head, so I believe we are. And I will say that I did mention it, we are kicking off a regional education campaign around the speed cameras and speed overall that's directed more regionally because half of what we're seeing are not just residents of San Francisco is people coming in and out of San Francisco. So we want to make sure that that message around speeding is heard regionally. And it sounds like— and I can find more information and get more information for you on any public information campaigns around red light cameras. Yeah, that will be very helpful in addition to learning the overall driver behaviors Thank you. Supervisor Dorsey. [192:38] Speaker 2: Thank you, Chair Melgar. I do want to express my appreciation to the department for its commitment to this, and I think for making sure that— [192:47] Speaker 6: I think San Francisco was the first of all the pilot cities to implement this and just to be out in front of everyone. [192:54] Speaker 2: And obviously anything I can do to be— to continue to be a cheerleader for this, it's really important in all of our districts. But I think the district I represent, we're really seeing how it's making things safer. Now that the program is up and running, it has been for 18 months. You know, I think we're seeing that it's effective. It's my understanding where it's reduced speeding by 80%. There are some streets, though, that may have design issues. And I just wanted to tease out, is there data that you're seeing that is helpful to inform how future quick builds or safety projects can be implemented, particularly around places like Bryant and Harrison adjacent to the freeway? [193:41] Speaker 1: Yes, I think that that's part of that relocation study that I was referring to, is just taking a good look at these camera locations and how they're performing both through the speed camera data, but also, you know, what are the other interventions happening there, and are we doing everything we can, and what's the best tool? And I think that's a lot of what we're looking at when we're going to be trying to test out maybe where to move a few to see how they fare and if it makes a difference. You know, I think on all of what we do, we're always trying to use our toolbox and figure out what combination of tools are the best interventions at a certain location given very different land uses, geographies, et cetera. Yes, I mean, Harrison and Bryan have much different qualities than some of the more residential streets. [194:38] Speaker 2: And then I was doing some research last month on just comparative massive use of surveillance technologies for traffic. And I saw that New York City had just celebrated the addition of 600— it's 600 red light cameras in a traffic that is probably North America's most surveilled. And we went out to even do congestion, look at congestion pricing. I mean, it's interesting what they're doing, but I was just It raised the question for me, are we looking at opportunities to expand and modernize our red light cameras? [195:20] Speaker 6: And I know that— [195:21] Speaker 2: does the pattern of the passage of AB 720 impact how we're thinking about the program? [195:27] Speaker 1: I can get back to you a little bit more on specifics around that, but I will say that there are opportunities to think about in the future being able to combine technologies in a way that allows for just more efficiencies and being able to expand. The 720 is a different Senate bill than how we currently implement our red light cameras, which are moving violations, and the 720 are still civil infractions. So it is a very different sort of repercussions, and we just have to be mindful of that as we move everything forward. But I'm certainly happy to get back to you on more red light-specific questions because I'm not the best person to answer that. [196:16] Speaker 2: Great, thanks. [196:18] Speaker 1: Okay, before I go back to you, Supervisor, I just wanted to ask a couple things. So, you know, I love the program. think we should have more of it. I understand that the limited resources that we had were deployed on the high-injury corridor. In the past, we've talked about high-risk versus high-injury, and we're trying to define what that is. But to me, high-risk is where there's vulnerable bodies. We saw in the statistics that SFPD presented that folks older than 65, and then now increasingly younger folks, like kids on scooters, are vulnerable. Just a few years ago, I remember when Supervisor Stephanie represented District 2, we had a horrific fatality of a teacher in front of one of our elementary schools. In my district, we have Brotherhood Way, which we continue to negotiate in terms of the speeds. And I wish we could do something like— I think even a dummy camera would help. I don't know if we can do that. But we have an assisted living facility, 3 schools, and a preschool on less than a mile. And so to me, that is a perfect example of where we want to slow people down because there's kids and older people coming back and forth all the time. And, you know, we don't have— I think this would be great to try to figure out some kind of enforcement. School zones for sure, you know, and then where there's older and disabled people. So have we considered anything like that in terms of like the next iteration of rolling out these things? No, I think you're absolutely right. Absolutely correct. And yes, our current locations have considered schools and our high injury network as per outlined directly in the bill. But future iterations and hopefully future iterations of the bill could hopefully expand where we're able to place things so that we can get more coverage around the areas that you're talking about, people generators, to be able to get those streets that are maybe not necessarily on the High Street network but are hubs for people and vulnerable users. Yeah, and I think like some of the reinvestments that this program is allowing for are being directed back into those residential streets where it— maybe it's not in the High Street corridor, but we know that they're around parks, around schools where there's a lot of kids and seniors using those areas. So I think it's something that's we're definitely thinking about and hopefully can keep front of mind as we move forward with this program, especially towards expansion. Okay, thank you. Supervisor Chen. Thank you, Chair Marga. Um, again, I— there's— there are more questions, um, from my office. Another very common question and concern that we hear a lot, it's about scooters. Um, scooters that are riding on pedestrian walkway and parking on the sidewalk? And how is SFMTA investing in education as a solution? Or like, what is your solution to help solving some of those concerns? Yeah, well, I know the MTA is doing multiple things to work around that effort, including workshops organized by the mayor's office, et cetera. The speed camera program doesn't specifically address any sort of scooter safety or regulation. We do have very strict privacy regulations that we have to follow as part of the bill that, you know, we only photograph the back license plate of the vehicle, no imagery, no facial recognition, anything like that. So we do have some very strict regulations that we have to adhere to as part of the speed camera program under AB 645. [200:28] Speaker 2: And if I may, Chair Melgar, speaking on behalf of the agency, I do know that to Ms. Lang's point, we are working very closely with the mayor's office and the chair herself and other advocates around creating a better, more robust education and awareness and response to the type of violations that you're seeing, Supervisor Chen, with scooters on the sidewalks and creating all kinds of havoc in commercial districts. Mm-hmm. It's a real issue that has been identified. Part of the problem for the MTA with that particular violation of riding scooters on the sidewalk is the fact that it is a moving violation. So we have limited, actually no authority to enforce moving violations. We are working closely with the scooter providers of the scooter share programs and working with them to educate their riders as part of their agreement to utilize the program not to do this. And we're making every effort we can to get the scooters like parked off the sidewalks in corrals and whatnot. But the great majority of the violations that I'm personally seeing are people that are private— are there scooters that are privately owned? And we really have no kind of authority over that. But the hope would be that with this e-mobility working group that they're going to kick off in the new year, uh, we'll be able to find more comprehensive approaches to addressing this very real problem that your constituents have identified. [202:01] Speaker 1: Great. And the other that I also would like I would also like to have you comment on the implementation of the High Injury Network Draft Plan. What is the progress of implementation? Can you repeat the question? Sorry. Can you— I would like to also hear from you about the implementation of the High Injury Network Draft Plan and what is the current progress? Well, I'll try to speak to that in general. But, I think if you're referring to just citywide programs around this hindering network and what we're doing there, I think you'll hear more about it tomorrow at the at the the Street Safety Initiative hearing. But you know, we are not only some of the things I mentioned in the beginning, not only looking at speed cameras, but things like. Speed limit reductions, and we've done a number of those. We're doing some traffic calming efforts and revamping that program. And then there's, you know, a continuation of our Quick Build improvement toolkit across the city and a number of other initiatives that we're working to do citywide to continue to address our hydrant network. And that's in addition to our Quick Build program that continues and corridor projects that we always have ongoing. And I'm sure that, you know, we'll continue to give you updates on that moving forward. Got it. And I'll ask more tomorrow. Thank you. Okay. Thank you so much, Supervisor. Thank you, folks from MTA. I appreciate it. With that, let's go to public comment. Okay. Yeah, let's go to public comment. Thank you, Madam Chair. [203:51] Speaker 2: Land Use and Transportation will now hear public comment related to agenda item number 7. If you have public comment for this item, please line up to speak along that western wall. We have a speaker at the lectern who's ready to begin. [204:02] Speaker 5: Okay, hello. [204:05] Speaker 1: Um, I don't have a driver's license, so I walk around a lot and use public transportation a lot. I also live in this high-injury network, so these are just my thoughts and reflections. As someone impacted by all this, I just got to remind people that the staffing shortage SFPD references is a theoretical staffing shortage, not a historical one. I don't think they've ever matched this theoretical setting they've set, and I don't know if they ever will. I heard a supervisor say that eight years ago is when he started questioning this whole traffic control SFPD response thing. We got a noncommittal answer from SFPD about when they'll get better about certain things. And so maybe in 2020— wait, 2034, in 8 years from now, we may or may not get anything from SFPD in this regard. [204:58] Speaker 2: Let's see. [205:00] Speaker 3: Perfect deflection. [205:01] Speaker 1: Oh yes, the department, SFPD, saying that they're understaffed is a perfect deflection for taking responsibility and accountability for their actions. and budgeting and where they staff people. The lower amount of officers committed to traffic enforcement reminded me of SFPD's SVU issue, where they also lowered the amount of investigators for sexual assault cases and had no standards there. So yeah, traffic control and sexual assault seem to be on the same par for them. SFPD towed 17 vehicles in 2026. We have ICE vehicles illegally parked at SFMTAs. 250 Clay Street garage. Maybe somebody can add a couple more vehicles to this total this year and tow those ICE vehicles out. We have a lot of congestion from Uber, Lyft, Waymo, etc. [205:48] Speaker 2: I'm sure that's causing a lot of frustration with drivers as well. [205:52] Speaker 1: Let's see. Oh, we are relying on SFPD captains to do certain things, but then we have stations like Mission and Southern SFPD stations where the captains are always rotating. So I don't think they ever really know how to do their job. Thank you for your comments. [206:07] Speaker 2: Let's have the next speaker, please. Good evening, Land Use and Transportation Committee. Griffin Lee here representing Connected SF and membership across the city. Thanks for bringing this hearing up. We are very much supportive of, of the different camera programs, red light cameras, speed enforcement. I think it's disrespectful to question PD and what they're doing on the streets to help protect and reduce fatalities and collisions. I mean, they're understaffed, 600, 700 officers, as Supervisor Dorsey mentioned, and they're doing, I think, the best they can. Lastly, this— what the civil grand jury report stated back in, I think it's 2024, 2025 now. [206:58] Speaker 3: 2024. The years are blurring. [207:01] Speaker 2: One of the key reasons, top 3 recommendations the civil grand jury had was continued enforcement. [207:10] Speaker 3: And we advocate for doubling down on enforcement. [207:16] Speaker 2: People are clearly feeling the effects of the punishment consequence of paying fines for camera speed infractions and red light cameras. [207:24] Speaker 9: Thank you. [207:25] Speaker 2: So thank you very much for the hearing and hope these words of wisdom help. Lastly, I will say I forgot to mention we're not going to design our— we're not going to design our way out of this crisis. I think one of the supervisors on this committee brought up a decent point around looking at some of the more confusing intersections like Mission Bay, 4th and Channel, Dubose Triangle. etc., but we're not going to design our way out of this. [207:54] Speaker 1: Thank you very much. Thank you for comments. [207:56] Speaker 2: Next speaker, please. [207:57] Speaker 1: Good afternoon, Chair Melgar and supervisors. My name is Jody Medeiros, and I'm the director of Walk San Francisco. Last night, we stood outside in the rain honoring the lives lost at the 12th Annual World Day of Remembrance for Road Traffic Victims, and we've lost 23 people since we stood there last year at this memorial. Thank you to Supervisor Mandelman, Melgar, and Dorsey for joining us there last night, and to Supervisor Mandelman for calling today's hearing. And I want to thank Commander Hu and his staff for sharing the department's work on enforcement, but we don't think this work goes far enough. We hear at Walk San Francisco all the time that speeding is rampant, and the data is showing that. We need safe speeds everywhere to reduce the chance and the severity of of crashes. The citation numbers presented today aren't adding up to what's needed for drivers to know that the laws will be enforced. The SFPD goal of Focus on the 5 for 50% of citations is because Focus on the 5 are the most dangerous driving behaviors, and therefore these are the types of behaviors that need to be eliminated to keep us safe. That is why it's really difficult to see in today's presentation that the Focus on the 5 is less than half of the citations being given. I'm also disappointed that the presentation included a slide about where pedestrians are, in or outside the sidewalk, when they're killed. I'm not sure how this fits into the purpose of today's hearing. I would have found it much more valuable to hear more details about the SFPD's work in cracking down on dangerous driving behavior to protect our most vulnerable, our seniors, our children, our residents, our visitors who are walking, biking, and scooting. Thank you so much, supervisors, for continuing to ask the police department the hard questions and to hold them accountable for making our streets safe. Thank you. [209:49] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. Let's have the next speaker, please. Good afternoon, Chair Melgar and supervisors. My name is Sam Greenberg. I'm the advocacy director at Walk San Francisco. Thank you for the commitment you showed in July by voting for Supervisor Dorsey's resolution to support state legislation to expand life-saving speed safety cameras in California. The share of drivers going 10 miles per hour above the speed limit or more is down 84% across camera locations. Speed safety cameras are resoundingly meeting their goals. And as the number one cause of severe and fatal collisions in San Francisco, Reducing dangerous speeding is crucial for achieving safe streets for all. Thank you to the SFMTA for the incredible work you've done to launch and operate the first speed camera program in the state. Walk SF is urging the mayor's office and the SFMTA to champion legislation in 2027 to expand speed safety cameras, and the community agrees. On our online action, over 800 emails have been sent to city leaders. We also believe expanding and modernizing red light cameras needs to be a priority for the SFMTA and for the city. New York City has 600 red light cameras compared to San Francisco's 19. That number was just 13 last week, but it took 5 years for those additional 6 cameras to be brought online. San Francisco should transition as quickly as possible to SB 720, which standardizes red light cameras with the sings the same strong privacy and equity protections as speed cameras and allows us to implement as many as we need to. The SFMTA should create a plan to add more cameras, and the city should fix the interdepartmental coordination challenges that have made it take 5 years just to add 6 red light cameras. It should not take so long to expand the use of this life-saving technology. [211:39] Speaker 1: Thank you. [211:39] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. Let's have the next speaker, please. Good afternoon, supervisors. Thank you for this important hearing. Um, I will just add 3 points so as not to repeat the excellent points already made by Jody and Sam. Uh, the first is one thing that wasn't mentioned today is to continue to explore the speeding in non-emergency city-owned vehicles. I think the city has great data on that, and it's surprising how many city-owned vehicles are still speeding within the city. The second is there was mention of a regional education campaign, and I think there's been great emphasis on how effective different other interventions are, such as the cameras, and we should bring that same evaluation orientation to the education campaigns. Many of you have probably heard the strong evidence of the impact of infrastructure and enforcement, but less so with education campaigns. [212:34] Speaker 1: And so I think it's protocol, we measure it. [212:35] Speaker 2: And then last, some quick low-hanging fruit since it was touched on earlier. Although enforcement isn't critical— is critical, it goes hand in hand with infrastructure. And right nearby to where I live, I'm in D10, but right nearby in D6, we have Channel and 4th where we've had some recent fatalities. And there's just a great need for us to just push the agency forward to launch a project to make Channel narrower and to put that bike lane on 4th. [213:02] Speaker 1: Thank you so much. [213:03] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. [213:04] Speaker 1: Let's have the next speaker, please. [213:05] Speaker 2: Good evening, supervisors. My name is Micah. [213:11] Speaker 3: I'm a resident of District 9, and I'm not sure we learned anything here today. [213:17] Speaker 2: We have all the information and tools we need to create safer streets, and enforcement is one part of that solution. With that being said, I'm disappointed that some of our city officials and especially our police department approach street safety with all the intellectual rigor of climate change denial. We aren't doing traffic enforcement because it's dangerous, because the department has an aging fleet, because they're understaffed, because our officers don't have the experience, because of the hills, because the districts are big. [213:50] Speaker 3: What are we talking about here? [213:53] Speaker 2: Listening to the presentation from the police today reminded me of one of my friend's favorite sayings. If he worked for me, he wouldn't work for me. Supervisors, I appreciate your attempts to drill into the specifics today, but I think the inability of the police to coherently diagnose the problem and outline a plan of action should be seriously concerning for everyone in this building and for everyone in this city. The police department is a service that we pay over $800 million a year for in San Francisco, and it doesn't work. I urge the supervisors to remember this when budget time comes around and to invest in real evidence-based solutions to street safety instead of more money for the police. We need infrastructure and redesigned streets. We need hardened protection for vulnerable road users. We need to massively expand automated enforcement. Yes, we need the police department to play a role, but we need measurable results and progress. And if we can't get results, then we shouldn't keep squandering city dollars on fixes that don't work. [214:51] Speaker 3: Thank you for your time. [214:52] Speaker 2: Thank you for your comments. Do we have anyone else who has public comment for agenda item number 7? Madam Chair. [214:59] Speaker 1: Thank you so much, and thank you, Commander Hu and SFPD, and thank you, MTA, for the presentations. I will give the last word to President Mindelman. Oh, sorry, public comment is up close. [215:16] Speaker 2: Thank you, Chair Melgar. Thank you to SFPD, NMTA, and all the folks who stayed through 3.5 hours to offer their public comment on this topic. I am— I mean, I'm enormously grateful for the work that these 2 departments are doing to increase enforcement, and I think It is, you know, it would be wrong not to acknowledge that we are in a better place around enforcement today than we were 5 years ago, and that is notwithstanding the continued erosion of numbers in the department. They're, you know, as Supervisor Dorsey said, you know, we're way off from what we need in the police department. That being said, I'm a little concerned that I don't really hear any plan or strategy or idea of how, if say a supervisor were to take up a hearing like this next year, the numbers would be showing continued improvement. And maybe just we're going to see improvements to staffing overall, and because of that there's going to be improvement to traffic enforcement, but I don't think that's That's exactly the way it works. I think probably it would be helpful for the department to— and I think this was— I think actually now Chief Jones, Commander Jones, after one of these hearings at one, you know, several years ago, she did actually sort of think about what, what was available in terms of resources available that the department had and what could be done to improve enforcement. And I think We're seeing the results of that, but I don't know if that continues to get us you know more numbers going forward. It does seem to me like traffic company needs to be rebuilt, and that that should be an important priority for the next year or two. And I hope it will be. I think this is a topic. I know this is a topic my constituents care a lot about, which is why I've continued. To revive this hearing. I think my colleagues are hearing about this from their constituents a lot, so I don't think it's going to go away. I do hope that someone will take up this particular piece of street safety, which is the enforcement piece. I think this hearing can probably end as I leave the board, so I would ask the committee to have this hearing heard and filed and someone else Okay, thank you, President Mandelman, and thank you for your ongoing efforts all these years to make progress on this. [218:06] Speaker 1: I appreciate it. And yes, we will keep talking about it. Thank you so much. So I want to make a motion that we file this hearing. [218:16] Speaker 2: On the motion offered by the Chair that this be heard and filed, Vice Chair Chen. [218:20] Speaker 1: Second. [218:21] Speaker 2: Chin, aye. Member Dorsey? [218:22] Speaker 9: Aye. [218:22] Speaker 1: Dorsey, aye. [218:23] Speaker 2: Chair Melgar? [218:23] Speaker 3: Aye. [218:24] Speaker 2: Melgar, aye. Madam Chair, there are 3 ayes. [218:26] Speaker 1: Thank you. Do we have anything else, uh, on our agenda? There is no further business. Okay, uh, before I adjourn the meeting, I just wanted to make sure everybody remembered that we are not meeting next Monday and this committee will come back after Thanksgiving. And with that, we are adjourned.